Moon in the 5th says you are primarily interested in a love relationship with him, not a friendship.
Moon separates from a square to both sun, him, and mars, his co-significator, showing the relationship hitting some bumpy points and disagreements, that you outlined.
It now approaches a sextile to Uranus, your co-ruler, so it comes back to you and the decision is yours.
Sun in 7th approaching a trine to Saturn, you, does promise a coming together, but you are retrograde and hiding from it.
The cusp of the 11th of the future, and friendship, is about to change, and its ruler Jupiter is retrograde conjunct ascendent, so you aren't happy to have just this level of contact with him, and things are about to change.
Venus of love expressing herself awkwardly in scorpio is exactly square the ascendent / descendent, another sign that this isn't going to work out. The energy just isn't lining up.
Finally, ruler of your 4th of endings, mercury, is retrograde moving towards a trine with Jupiter, ruler of his 4th, on ascendent, so the two of you may just agree to disagree as they say, and part ways for now.
Mercury then makes an uncomfortable square with pluto in your 12th. Pluto likes to throw everything up in the air to start from scratch.
The 4th is also family and home, so you may also be receiving negative input from them about the relationship.