Let me try here. Mars and Saturn are both malefics. One of them is going to be team native, and one won't. They're still both malefics, though. It will come down to the individual chart, but in a perfect, sect-less chart, I wouldn't want either of them. I'd want them both in reasonably good shape (not retrograde, not combust, in some dignity), and in the right hemispheres. For a day chart that would be Saturn above the horizon, Mars below. Reverse that for night charts.
I'd want the benefics to be in good shape, too. Jupiter in a night chart in bad shape could lead the native astray. It's nature is to do good, so it will always try to, but if it's in bad shape, it may only mitigate disaster a bit. It works better in a day chart overall, and again, you'd want it above the horizon, and Venus below the horizon in the day, reverse for night.
Planets that are out of sect can be harmful, can represent things other people do (maybe even good things), can be pleasant diversions, or can seem to do not much of anything. It's going to depend on the chart.
Also, traditional astrology is predictive. We don't see the planets all in play all the time. Maybe a planet is only going to do one thing in your chart, and that's it.