Will this TOL work?

Salasi

Well-known member
I asked if b will come back to me.

Me as venus in its detriment and he as mars also in its detriment. And moon, also in its detriment, will make a TOL from venus to mars. So i wonder if this TOL will work out with all planets in its detriment?

Chart: https://ibb.co/nKt2xm
 
Last edited:

Sunrise

Well-known member
I asked if b will come back to me.

Me as venus in its detriment and he as mars also in its detriment. And moon, also in its detriment, will make a TOL from venus to mars. So i wonder if this TOL will work out with all planets in its detriment?

Chart: https://ibb.co/nKt2xm

Hi!
Yes can work this transfer of light! Moon is in triplicity of Venus and also in exaltation of mars....
 

Chrysalis

Well-known member
I think it should work, even though your both in detriment you at least both receive each other, and you both recieve moon too.

All being in detriment though may mean it will take some time.
 

Salasi

Well-known member
Thanks a lot for your reply sunrise ans chrysalis :)

About the delays you mention, actually my question was if he would come back before february. So maybe it might indicate it will be after february?
 

JUPITERASC

Well-known member
Thanks a lot for your reply sunrise ans chrysalis :)

About the delays you mention,
actually my question was if he would come back before february. So maybe it might indicate it will be after february?
Detriment is not necessarily related to timing/delays :smile:
 

JUPITERASC

Well-known member
thanks a lot for your answer jupiterasc! :)
May i ask you, for learning purposes, what do you think the influence
of all these detriments might be ?
Tsmall, Tikana or Rafaella are our forum experts Salasi - I'm no expert :smile:
and you may not be aware of Skyscript FREE online HORARY course
It's complete with self-testing in realtime with answers!
a
t http://www.skyscript.co.uk/horary_intro.html

there is also a detailed explanation of DETRIMENT there as well at

http://www.skyscript.co.uk/dig4.html

and
a thread discussion on timing
with TOL
http://www.astrologyweekly.com/forum/showthread.php?t=20889&highlight=timing
 

Salasi

Well-known member
Thanks for the info jupiterasc. I am aware of this info on the net and i have read it before. Also this link from bonnati i had read http://www.horary.com/guests/horaryrh.html

Most of this info talks about the destruction of the matter if one of the significators is in detriment... But in this case there is also quite strong reception between the significators... Hence my question if the TOL could still work despite the detriment... And if so, i was wondering what influence it might have on the outcome :)
 

Salasi

Well-known member
Just an update... He did not come back... (my question was if b would come back before february)... But we are communicating again on a friendly basis since a couple of weeks (before there was no communication at all)...so maybe who knows, its like chrysalis say, it will take some time...so meaning maybe longer than expected?
 
Last edited:

tikana

Well-known member
how did you guys even come up with a yes

so venus is weak
mars is weak
moon is weak

I would have said something might happen but relationship wont happen at all .. due to weakness and lack of interest
 

Salasi

Well-known member
how did you guys even come up with a yes

so venus is weak
mars is weak
moon is weak

I would have said something might happen but relationship wont happen at all .. due to weakness and lack of interest

thanks for your reply tikana. Makes total sense what you say :) now i better understand the influence of planets in their detriment.
 
Top