Hi all
I find this thread very interesting and for most reasons as others have said before; usually having to do with whether we really have free will or not; etc. I think there are some great answers pertaining to that and so, I'll leave that part of it for now.
What I wanted to know is how to identify patterns. I've been looking at some charts (about 20) of different serial killers and there is really no conclusive pattern that I can find - to say oh, this guy has mars here, so he must be...
- I also tried to look at killers born in different decades, since I realise a lot of the outer planets will have similar aspects for everyone born within a certain generation; I say this in reference to Neptune sextile Pluto which was 1 aspect that I kept picking up in all their charts (and all btwn 0-5degrees). But I've seen this sextile between these 2 planets will last for some years to come, so cannot be to blame.
- I think I also saw that, with this sextile, there is almost always a third, more personal planet in the mix being Sun (usually in 12th) or mercury or mars badly aspected, and usually to pluto in retrograde.
But then again, it's not all conclusive.
So I was wondering, would it be better (instead of looking for 1 or few standard placements) would it not be better to look at their M.O. sort of like profiling. I think when I broke it down to the types of crimes they commited, the patterns seemed to show up more clearly.
For instance - killers who mudered men or boys almost always had dominant saturn placements that were in opposition to mars and almost always squared to chiron or the moon. Usually profilers would say they kill men because of some strong authoritative male figure in the past who mistreated them in some way that they have not been able to get over emotionally.
For those that killed women, there were squares from venus or the moon to Jupiter/ Neptune and or Saturn and the planets are often in retrograde
There was one I found (Marc Dutroux) who killed children and he had mars in 4th house (Pisces) semi-sq 4H ruler Neptune, which was in 12th house Scorpio, and Neptune sextiled Pluto in 10th house at 0-degree. Saturn in 1H was also square Pluto.
I'm just giving these placements to say that I'm not sure how there can be a dominant characteristic. I also don't know if anyone has brought up this way to look at their charts (I'm fairly new to astrology - under a year - and still have tons more to learn) but I think it might help as a way of looking at surrounding influences too like many others here have already pointed out. Though, going back to the very 1st post, if astrologers were able to point out that they were serial killers, then I think there must be some pattern or dominant placement.
I just find it hard to think that it is so set (back to the freewill/ fate discussion).
I have a question; I read through the whole blog, but I don't remember if there was any mention to transits; I was wondering because I know they have a 'cool down' period between acts, so could there be a dominant transit that could maybe set someone off in this type of way?
Sorry for the long post and I don't think I expressed myself very clearly, but if anyone gets my drift please let me know if astrologers work by any patterns of identification- and what's the most common one; or answer the question above please. Thx.
And feel free to pick apart this post