One simple question, one yes or no..

fullmoonlibra

fullmoonlibra

Well-known member
Are transits through a house in a progressed chart more relevant and accurate than transits through the regular natal chart?

The reason I ask this is because of the expectation that I had about Jupiter transiting through my natal 9th and 10th house, and there were only dissapointments.
Now, Jupiter is very close to my progressed MC Chiron in Gemini, and I was thinking if it would affect my ideals to become writer.
 
aquarius7000

aquarius7000

Well-known member
Hi,

Not a stupid question at all.

Well, if a natal house has planets, which are being touched by transiting planet(s) and progressed planet(s), then there is more pressure/activity in that particular house, isn't there?

As to your having had expectations of a planet, presently Jupiter, well, Jupiter won't always do what you 'expect' it to. Sometimes there are blessings in disguise that are not noticed instantaneously.

:)AQ7
 
IleneK

IleneK

Premium Member
fullmoonlibra said:
Are transits through a house in a progressed chart more relevant and accurate than transits through the regular natal chart?

The reason I ask this is because of the expectation that I had about Jupiter transiting through my natal 9th and 10th house, and there were only dissapointments.
Now, Jupiter is very close to my progressed MC Chiron in Gemini, and I was thinking if it would affect my ideals to become writer.
Click to expand...

Hi, flm.

There is some question as to whether transits to a progressed chart are meaningful. We usually examine a transit or progression to the natal chart. Or we look at transits to transits or progressed to progressed, within certain exceptions.

So to answer your question, I would say that transits through your natal chart are more relevant and accurate than transits through your progressed chart.
 
fullmoonlibra

fullmoonlibra

Well-known member
IleneK said:
Hi, flm.

There is some question as to whether transits to a progressed chart are meaningful. We usually examine a transit or progression to the natal chart. Or we look at transits to transits or progressed to progressed, within certain exceptions.

So to answer your question, I would say that transits through your natal chart are more relevant and accurate than transits through your progressed chart.
Click to expand...

I see..
But I don't understand the working from the red progression lines on astro.com, at the 'natal, transits and progressions combined' - section.
What meaning does the space of the line have?
 
fullmoonlibra

fullmoonlibra

Well-known member
aquarius7000 said:
Hi,

Not a stupid question at all.

Well, if a natal house has planets, which are being touched by transiting planet(s) and progressed planet(s), then there is more pressure/activity in that particular house, isn't there?

As to your having had expectations of a planet, presently Jupiter, well, Jupiter won't always do what you 'expect' it to. Sometimes there are blessings in disguise that are not noticed instantaneously.

:)AQ7
Click to expand...

I hope you are right. My education went bad and got restricted when Jupiter was transiting the 9th house. I have my Sun conjunct NN in the 9th house and besides an opposite to Pluto, all trines to Neptune, Mars, ASC and Uranus..
So, in stead of improvement, I changed from school..
And when Jupiter transit was conjunct my Venus/MC (10th), I quit school..
 
Last edited:
IleneK

IleneK

Premium Member
fullmoonlibra said:
I see..
But I don't understand the working from the red progression lines on astro.com, at the 'natal, transits and progressions combined' - section.
What meaning does the space of the line have?
Click to expand...

I think I know what you are talking about, but not exactly sure what chart you are referring to. If you would want to upload it here, I would be glad to try to address your questions.
 
aquarius7000

aquarius7000

Well-known member
Hi,
fullmoonlibra said:
....went bad and got restricted when Jupiter was transiting the 9th house. I have my Sun conjunct NN in the 9th house and besides an opposite to Pluto, all trines to Neptune, Mars, ASC and Uranus..
So, in stead of improvement, I changed from school..
And when Jupiter transit was conjunct my Venus/MC (10th), I quit school..
Click to expand...
Well, what needs to be realised is that it's never just one planet (Jup) transiting your chart alone. There are other influences as well, plus also circumstances, opportunities you get and what you make of them.

:)AQ7
 
Top