Saturn opposite ascendant--am I doomed to a life time of unsatisfying relationships?

wan

Well-known member
Its not what we think.... If the time is 8:25 PM, on August 2, then it appears at first that it was that was Daylight time in Taiwan, not Standard Time. And daylight time means that you have an Aquarius ascendant whether you want it or not.

So the real question here is whether there was daylight time or standard time in Taiwan at that time. AstrolDeluxe says that it was Daylight time. Solar Fire says that it was Standard time. I didn't know which is which.

So more sleuthing......

According to Wiki, DST in Taiwan is a checkered thing:

"Taiwan implemented DST from 1945–61, revoked DST from 1962-73, reinstated DST from 1974–75, revoked DST from 1976-79 and reinstated it in 1980. Taiwan abandoned DST from 1981 onwards."

This means that there was no DST in Taiwan when you were born, so you actually have Pisces rising, not Aquarius, provided that your mother's wrist watch was correct.

There was no daylight saving in Taiwan in 1979? But my mother said there was. Who is right?
 

Zarathu

Account Closed
Last edited:

wan

Well-known member
Until this is determined, there is no way to know what your astrological chart consists of.

This says there was DST in Taiwan at your birth:

http://www.timeanddate.com/time/zone/taiwan/taipei

If there was then your ASC is in Aquarius. Who to believe?

Really? However I tried using the free chart services of astrodienst (http://www.astro.com/cgi/ade.cgi, go to extended chart selection), which according to someone is a reputable website with very reliable services, and it showed that my ascendant is Pisces. I also used http://alabe.com/cgi-bin/chart/astr...ung&COUNTRY=TAIW&STATE=&INPUT9=&Submit=Submit and it also told me Pisces. But some other services said Aquarius.
 
Last edited:

Zarathu

Account Closed
Really? However I tried using the free chart services of astrodienst (http://www.astro.com/cgi/ade.cgi, go to extended chart selection), which according to someone is a reputable website with very reliable services, and it showed that my ascendant is Pisces. I also used http://alabe.com/cgi-bin/chart/astr...ung&COUNTRY=TAIW&STATE=&INPUT9=&Submit=Submit and it also told me Pisces. But some other services said Aquarius.

Listen.... the problem between the two is whether the charting service or program is using your birth as being Daylight saving time or not.

If its standard time, then you have a Pisces ASC

If its DT then you have an Aquarius ASC.

The problem here is to find out which it really was, since some sources say that Taiwan was using DT time then, and other sources say it was not. And besides that your mother says something else, but that was almost 36 years ago. I don't remember stuff that far back. Since wiki gave a specific time when it wasn't and when it was, I tend to believe Wiki. World Time.com also says that Taiwan was using DT in 1979. But if you are going to believe you mother, then you have an Aquarius ASC.

This is the best I can do for you. Search the internet; collect different sources; choose the one that more agree with. I don't have time to do extensive searching about this for you.

But I would tend to believe that you have a DT birth time. This means that you have an Aquarius ASC.

And it comes back to my previous question about how hard you want to work with this.
 
Last edited:

Zarathu

Account Closed
I have just checked with the publisher of my software who tells me that Daylight savings time was in effect in Taiwan in 1979, using two different sources. Since John Haloran is extremely oriented to accuracy, I would go with DT.

This means that AFAIC, your birth was during DT. And this means, while you may think that you have Pisces ASC,

You do not. Its Aquarius.
 

helgaleena

Well-known member
I agree with everything everyone is saying!! It might not be 'all you' that this Saturn placement is causing in your life, but it's obvious that you will have better luck changing your own attitudes about the situation than other people!

You are not 'doomed'. You are 'challenged'. You are a very efficient person at dealing with challenges in other parts of your life, and it's possible to select among your dreams the ones you most wish to believe in and give faith to.

Here is a chart with the north and south nodes aspected. I also added Part of Fortune, Vertex, and Lilith.

http://www.astro.com/cgi/chart.cgi?...=20&add=22&snode=-Ys&aspc=1&aspn=1&asp=1&ast=

Part of Fortune, your true happiness, is conjunct your Moon. Your moon has a sextile to seventh house Vertex. That means that you are going to meet someone who will give you great happiness at some point. Jupiter, Neptune, Pluto, are related in a fortunate 'bow' formation connected to your Midheaven career. Of them, Pluto, the transformer, is in seventh house of relationships. When you meet this person it will be related to work, perhaps at a business trip or convention.

Will you calm down now and be more optimistic about your sixth house life path??? :cool:
 

JUPITERASC

Well-known member
Its not what we think.... If the time is 8:25 PM, on August 2, then it appears at first that it was that was Daylight time in Taiwan, not Standard Time. And daylight time means that you have an Aquarius ascendant whether you want it or not.

So the real question here is whether there was daylight time or standard time in Taiwan at that time. AstrolDeluxe says that it was Daylight time. Solar Fire says that it was Standard time. I didn't know which is which.

So more sleuthing......

According to Wiki, DST in Taiwan is a checkered thing:

"Taiwan implemented DST from 1945–61, revoked DST from 1962-73, reinstated DST from 1974–75, revoked DST from 1976-79 and reinstated it in 1980. Taiwan abandoned DST from 1981 onwards."

This means that there was no DST in Taiwan when you were born, so you actually have Pisces rising, not Aquarius, provided that your mother's wrist watch was correct.
There was DST in Taiwan when the OP was born :smile:
So assuming that your chart is correct, then the Saturn Opp ASC aspect that I alluded to at at first still remains. But at age 35, your 2ndary progressed chart is probably more indicative of the challenges thatyou are experiencing, than your natal except for the unresolved oppositions.

You, of course, still have to deal with your natal abilities and tendencies such as your out of bounds Mars(the prankster actually), the extremely high latitude Moon, and the very high friction 5th and 11th houses, making it difficult for you to function smoothly in both friendship and romance.

And the question remains how deeply you want to delve into the issues? Are you looking for a one shot deal of a couple of posts or are you looking for three hundred pages of description spread over months with a lot of introspection?

One is an "Ah-Hah!" moment, and the other is a lot of hard work. Most people, in my experience, want the simple silver bullet answer, and do not want to use their chart for the kind of introspection that changes lives.
Not only are there no silver bullets
there are also no werewolves
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silver_bullet

There was no daylight saving in Taiwan in 1979?
But my mother said there was. Who is right?
Your mother is right
there DEFINITELY WAS DST in Taiwan in 1979

According to this website (http://www.timeanddate.com/time/dst/1979b.html), there was daylight saving in Taiwan in 1979.

I am very confused right now. Different sources tell me different things.
Time and Date website is correct also

and

there was indeed DST in Taiwan in 1979


Until this is determined, there is no way to know what your astrological chart consists of.

This says there was DST in Taiwan at your birth:

http://www.timeanddate.com/time/zone/taiwan/taipei

If there was then your ASC is in Aquarius. Who to believe?
Correct. There was DST in Taiwan in 1979

and

the accurate natal Ascendant is now simply entirely dependent on
an accurate time of birth

Really? However I tried using the free chart services of astrodienst (http://www.astro.com/cgi/ade.cgi, go to extended chart selection), which according to someone is a reputable website with very reliable services, and it showed that my ascendant is Pisces. I also used http://alabe.com/cgi-bin/chart/astr...ung&COUNTRY=TAIW&STATE=&INPUT9=&Submit=Submit and it also told me Pisces. But some other services said Aquarius.
I can confirm that
astrodienst shows a Pisces ascendant
for the birthtime of 8.25PM


Listen.... the problem between the two is whether the charting service or program is using your birth as being Daylight saving time or not.

If its standard time, then you have a Pisces ASC

If its DT then you have an Aquarius ASC.

The problem here is to find out which it really was, since some sources say that Taiwan was using DT time then, and other sources say it was not.

And besides that your mother says something else,
but that was almost 36 years ago.
I don't remember stuff that far back.

Since wiki gave a specific time when it wasn't and when it was, I tend to believe Wiki. World Time.com also says that Taiwan was using DT in 1979. But if you are going to believe you mother, then you have an Aquarius ASC.

This is the best I can do for you. Search the internet; collect different sources; choose the one that more agree with. I don't have time to do extensive searching about this for you.

But I would tend to believe that you have a DT birth time. This means that you have an Aquarius ASC.

And it comes back to my previous question about how hard you want to work with this.
Because the OP's mother remembered correctly
that 'almost 36 years previously'
THERE WAS DAYLIGHT SAVINGS TIME

then
the OP's mother may indeed correctly recall the 'wristwatch time of birth' as described by the OP

I have just checked with the publisher of my software who tells me that Daylight savings time was in effect in Taiwan in 1979, using two different sources. Since John Haloran is extremely oriented to accuracy, I would go with DT.

This means that AFAIC, your birth was during DT. And this means, while you may think that you have Pisces ASC,

You do not. Its Aquarius.

Indeed, there WAS daylight savings time in Taiwan in 1979

AND FURTHERMORE

I have checked with
not only astrodienst
but also
with DELPHIC ORACLE software
http://www.astrology-x-files.com/

with the given time of 8.25PM

and

the OP indeed has a 12 degree PISCES ascendant
 

wan

Well-known member
First of all, thanks to all who replied.

Now, special, extra thanks go to both Zarathu and JupiterASC for going the extra mile to help me out. That being said, the two of you are telling me different things. JupiterASC said my ascendant is in Pisces, and zarathu said Aquarius. Again, two different things. So who should I listen to?
 

Zarathu

Account Closed
First of all, thanks to all who replied.

Now, special, extra thanks go to both Zarathu and JupiterASC for going the extra mile to help me out. That being said, the two of you are telling me different things. JupiterASC said my ascendant is in Pisces, and zarathu said Aquarius. Again, two different things. So who should I listen to?

The problem here is the actual time, now that we know that daylight time was actually in effect.

So much has gone by here that I've lost track of what you believe the time to be. Is it 8:25 PM CHDT or 9:25 PM CHDT?
 

wan

Well-known member
The actual, legal, "wrist-watch time", according to my mom, was 8:25 PM. This time has not yet been adjusted to compensate for daylight savings.

The two sources I used, astrodienst and astrolabe (see links here: http://www.astro.com, go to extended chart selection and http://alabe.com/cgi-bin/chart/astr...ung&COUNTRY=TAIW&STATE=&INPUT9=&Submit=Submit) both said my ascendant is Pisces 12 degree.

However, according to this source, http://astro.cafeastrology.com/cgi-...ur=20&d1min=25&city=kaohsiung,+taiwan&lang=en, it said my ascendant is in Aquarius 23.
 

helgaleena

Well-known member
The actual, legal, "wrist-watch time", according to my mom, was 8:25 PM. This time has not yet been adjusted to compensate for daylight savings.

The two sources I used, astrodienst and astrolabe (see links here: http://www.astro.com, go to extended chart selection and http://alabe.com/cgi-bin/chart/astr...ung&COUNTRY=TAIW&STATE=&INPUT9=&Submit=Submit) both said my ascendant is Pisces 12 degree.

However, according to this source, http://astro.cafeastrology.com/cgi-...ur=20&d1min=25&city=kaohsiung,+taiwan&lang=en, it said my ascendant is in Aquarius 23.


The two times you gave resulted by my calculations either in Pisces or Aries ascendant! Aquarius would be putting the Daylight savings in backwards. You are supposed to gain an hour in springtime, right? So listen to ME and stay Pisces rising :cool:
 

wan

Well-known member
The two times you gave resulted by my calculations either in Pisces or Aries ascendant! Aquarius would be putting the Daylight savings in backwards. You are supposed to gain an hour in springtime, right? So listen to ME and stay Pisces rising :cool:

I actually really hope that you are right. If I have Pisces rising at 12 degree, I have this very sexy (to me, anyway) configuration whereby the lord of the horoscope conjunct Midheaven and Saturn conjunct descendant.

But I am very confused about the whole Daylight savings thing and how to account for it in birth charts. I never know whether to add or subtract an hour.
 

helgaleena

Well-known member
I actually really hope that you are right. If I have Pisces rising at 12 degree, I have this very sexy (to me, anyway) configuration whereby the lord of the horoscope conjunct Midheaven and Saturn conjunct descendant.

But I am very confused about the whole Daylight savings thing and how to account for it in birth charts. I never know whether to add or subtract an hour.

'Spring forward, fall back' is the saying we learned about how to change your clocks.

You realize that the aspects will remain the same whether your rising sign is Pisces or not? The only thing which will shift is house position in some cases, not all cases. I would not worry too much about it. Saturn remains in the 6th and remains conjunct your north node but not as near the descendant.
 
Last edited:

wan

Well-known member
'Spring forward, fall back' is the saying we learned about how to change your clocks.

You realize that the aspects will remain the same whether your rising sign is Pisces or not? The only thing which will shift is house position in some cases, not all cases. I would not worry too much about it. Saturn remains in the 6th and remains conjunct your north node and very near the descendant.

True. However, angles (such as the ascendant) are very important in synastry and if I have ascendant at Pisces 12, I will be right on the sun-moon mid-point of this guy I like (or nearly so). If I have Aquarius at 23 degrees, no such sexiness.

Also, you said, "spring forward, fall back", that is only used to adjust the clock. When we are trying to take daylight savings time into account for horoscope chart purposes, I am not sure if that is also what we do. In fact, I remember this huge debate being carried out by two posters back on this web forum I used to visit, and they each believed they were the right one, they were equally forceful and confidant, but one of them said to put the clock back one hour and the other said to put it forward one hour. Nobody knew who was right.
 
Last edited:

helgaleena

Well-known member
True. However, angles (such as the ascendant) are very important in synastry and if I have ascendant at Pisces 12, I will be right on the sun-moon mid-point of this guy I like (or nearly so). If I have Aquarius at 23 degrees, no such sexiness.

Also, you said, "spring forward, fall back", that is only used to adjust the clock. When we are trying to take daylight savings time into account for horoscope chart purposes, I am not sure if that is also what we do. In fact, I remember this huge debate being carried out by two posters back on this web forum I used to visit, and they each believed they were the right one, they were equally forceful and confidant, but one of them said to put the clock back one hour and the other said to put it forward one hour. Nobody knew who was right.

In the spring you put it forward. In the fall you put it back. :wink:
 

JUPITERASC

Well-known member
True. However, angles (such as the ascendant) are very important in synastry and if I have ascendant at Pisces 12, I will be right on the sun-moon mid-point of this guy I like (or nearly so). If I have Aquarius at 23 degrees, no such sexiness.

Also, you said, "spring forward, fall back", that is only used to adjust the clock. When we are trying to take daylight savings time into account for horoscope chart purposes, I am not sure if that is also what we do. In fact, I remember this huge debate being carried out by two posters back on this web forum I used to visit, and they each believed they were the right one, they were equally forceful and confidant, but one of them said to put the clock back one hour and the other said to put it forward one hour. Nobody knew who was right.
Your Ascendant for the given time of 8.25PM is 12 degrees Pisces :smile:
 

JUPITERASC

Well-known member
I actually really hope that you are right. If I have Pisces rising at 12 degree, I have this very sexy (to me, anyway) configuration whereby the lord of the horoscope conjunct Midheaven and Saturn conjunct descendant.

But I am very confused about the whole Daylight savings thing and how to account for it in birth charts. I never know whether to add or subtract an hour.
CALCULATING A NATAL CHART BY HAND
EXAMPLE FROM KEN WARD'S ASTROLOGY PAGES
http://www.trans4mind.com/personal_d...ns/calcGMT.htm

Astrology: Calculating the Chart - UT or GMT.

QUOTE

'….While few people are actually going to work out astrological charts by hand, that is, using paper, pencil,
it is important to know how to do it
because unless an astrologer spends a great deal of time doing charts by hand,
they will never fully understand astrology.
By doing charts by hand,
one begins to understand more about the movement of the planets
and how they combine to affect the lives of people on Earth.
Astrology is a sacred science
and by doing the mundane routine things,
our minds enter a meditative state
wherein we realise things we might not have been able to know or understand otherwise....'

The tools you require to make a horoscope
in addition to writing
and
drawing tools
are
an atlas and an ephemeris
:smile:

An ephemeris is a book or booklet
containing information about the positions of planets, etc.
http://www.amazon.com/The-American-Ephemeris-1950-2050-Midnight/dp/1934976288


The information you require is the date and time and place of birth.


The place of birth is expressed in longitude and latitude.

Universal Time, or Greenwich Mean Time is required
to calculate the positions of the planets.




THE FOLLOWING LINKS ARE FOR THOSE WHO PREFER TO USE A TABLE OF HOUSES



CALCULATING A NATAL CHART BY HAND http://www.astrologicallyspeaking.co...ulatechart.pdf

QUOTE

'….For some time, our NCGR Chapters have asked for an available example of how to set a natal chart.
During the Spring 2010 Board meeting, it was voted that NCGR would place such an example on its website,
utilizing as a resource, Joan Negus’ out-of-print workbook, Basic Astrology: a Practical Guide.
This particular work was chosen
because it offers a time-proven resource for learning to accurately set a natal chart
and is an excellent way to honor Joan
since she and Ken Negus were instrumental in helping to establish the NCGR education program.
Ken Negus was contacted for permission to utilize Joan’s workbook, which he gave.....'



INSTRUCTIONS
HOW TO SET A NATAL CHART
http://www.geocosmic.org/educ/assets/chartcalc.pdf



QUOTE

'….Two resources that one must have available to set a chart are:

1. Table of Houses
2. Ephemeris of the year of birth.


Many examples are found in tables of houses and some ephemerides.


Examples given herein yield acceptable results for exams. One may calculate by hand or by calculator, both methods are included.


NB

Hand and/or computer calculating
does not always yield exactly to the minute and second
the same results as from astrological software
:smile:

In fact,
not all astrological software yields exactly to the minute-second
the same results
as another astrological software
,
thus a small amount of error is accepted by exams
.....'
 

wan

Well-known member
Thanks for the info, JupiterASC. However, I just emailed Astrodienst and they told me that their databases were not up to date. In other words, I AM an Aquarius rising.
 
Top