Not if a planet in another sign
Asce libra..L7 in H1 mars sco..
Yes, it would mean quesited is in the querent's 12th sign/house, rather than sharing querent's 1st sign/house. So you can work with the meaning from that perspective and get some info.Oh is it, i wasn't aware of this.
So if quesited is in 1st house but in another sign, then being in the querents 1st house means nothing as they are in a different sign or would it still mean something at least ?
Yes, it would mean quesited is in the querent's 12th sign/house, rather than sharing querent's 1st sign/house. So you can work with the meaning from that perspective and get some info.
So if im understanding this correctly, then say asc is on cancer, quesited is in querents 1st house but in the sign of Leo....so because quesited is in the sign of leo and not cancer, then we put quesited in the 12th house ?
Sorry I did not pay better attention to the signs in OP's example. By whole signs, quesited in OPs example would be in the sign after the asc, so in the 2nd, rather than the 12th
And going to your example above, as you say, if asc is Cancer and quesited is in Leo, then that puts quesited in the 2nd whole sign.
Alternately, if asc is Cancer and quesited in Gemini, that puts quesited in the 12th whole sign.
In either case, it puts quesited in an adjacent house, 2nd or 12th.
Then going a step further, signifiers being in adjacent signs are disjunct, so it is not considered favorable.
Oh yes i totally forgot you go by whole signs....so what you previously said and say now makes sense with regards to the wholesign system.
Ive delved into wholesigns before but then keep going back to regio ...im still not 100% which one i should use
Maybe Tik can answer my question then of if in a regio chart quesited is in 1st house, but in a different sign to what the asc sign is how would this differ in the meaning.
I use both region and whole signs when looking at each chart, gaining info from each perspective. Whole signs is the referee when things get ambiguous, like this example when two signs are in one house.
Yes, it will be good to hear Tik's, Rafaella's or other's comments.
This reminds me of a previous horary I posted.
Quesited was Mars in a Venus Sign in 12th house. I was Venus. He liked me but was unable to act due to not being single.
Venus in its own sign and in first house. Venus being so good was his good opinion of me.
12th house is an unable to act house.
so what is the answer ? if it work as yes or no
Because it is a cadent house yes
so what is the answer ? if it work as yes or no . if you was 25 libra in his TL3.and quiested is mars in scoripo .the question if he intersted and iam in his mind .then i consider the answer is no
Yes any significator placed in 6th/8th/12th house won't be able to act, either because they just don't want to or for a specific reason...past aspects from them usually tell you why.
Yes any significator placed in 6th/8th/12th house won't be able to act, either because they just don't want to or for a specific reason...past aspects from them usually tell you why.
in my 9th house his 3rd houseIn his what ?