difference between Aquarius moon & Pisces moon

emotionalaquarius

Active member
Hi there :)
I have Capricorn sun, Aquarius Moon in Vedic astrology.
I have Aquarius sun, Pisces moon in Natal Astrology.
I'm just wondering how that would play out? Which one do you think it more correct? air and water moons are very different in the way they handle emotions.
 

david starling

Well-known member
Hi there :)
I have Capricorn sun, Aquarius Moon in Vedic astrology.
I have Aquarius sun, Pisces moon in Natal Astrology.
I'm just wondering how that would play out? Which one do you think it more correct? air and water moons are very different in the way they handle emotions.

I think you meant "Tropical Astrology", rather than "Natal", which applies to any "Birth" Chart. Aquarius Sun, Pisces Moon is often very emotional, but is capable of emotional detachment. Capricorn Sun, Aquarius Moon is much more detached, emotionally speaking.
 

JUPITERASC

Well-known member
Hi there :)
I have Capricorn sun, Aquarius Moon in Vedic astrology.
I have Aquarius sun, Pisces moon in Natal Astrology.
I'm just wondering how that would play out?
Which one do you think it more correct?
A mile is not a "more correct form of measurement" than a kilometer :smile:
miles and kilometers are simply two of the many alternative ways of measuring distance
Similarly with VEDIC astrology and TROPICAL ASTROLOGY
these are two different methodologies of astrology

BRIEF VISUAL VIDEO EXPLANATION OF TROPICAL AND SIDEREAL
measurement
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=82p-DYgGFjI&feature=related


air and water moons are very different in the way they handle emotions.
that's another great example of generalisation being so much fun
and yet so uneliable

because

"AIR moons" = Gemini, Libra, Aquarius

clearly a GEMINI Moon ruler is MERCURY
and since Mercury may be placed in any of twelve different SIGNS
as well as in any of twelve different houses

in aspects that differ from natal chart to natal chart
then
Gemini Moons are not identical regarding the handling of emotion

similarly a LIBRA Moon ruler is VENUS
and since Venus may be placed in any of twelve different SIGNS
as well as in any of twelve different houses
in aspects that differ from natal chart to natal chart
then
LIBRA Moons are not identical regarding the handling of emotion


AQUARIUS Moon ruler is SATURN
and since Saturn may be placed in any of twelve different SIGNS
as well as in any of twelve different houses

in aspects that differ from natal chart to natal chart
then
AQUARIUS Moons are not identical regarding the handling of emotion


"WATER moons" = Cancer, Scorpio, Pisces

clearly Moon ruler is in own domicile in Cancer
however a Cancer Moon may be found in any of twelve different houses
in aspect with planets that differ from natal chart to natal chart
CANCER Moons are therefore not identical regarding the handling of emotion


SCORPIO Moon ruler is MARS
and since Mars may be placed in any of twelve different SIGNS
as well as in any of twelve different houses
in aspects that differ from natal chart to natal chart
then
SCORPIO Moons are not identical regarding the handling of emotion


PISCES Moon ruler is JUPITER
and since Jupiter may be placed in any of twelve different SIGNS
as well as in any of twelve different houses
in aspects that differ from natal chart to natal chart
then
PISCES
Moons are not identical regarding the handling of emotion

 

katydid

Well-known member
Hi there :)
I have Capricorn sun, Aquarius Moon in Vedic astrology.
I have Aquarius sun, Pisces moon in Natal Astrology.
I'm just wondering how that would play out? Which one do you think it more correct? air and water moons are very different in the way they handle emotions.

An aquarius moon in vedic and a pisces moon in western mean the same thing.

A rose by any other name, smells just as sweet. :sideways:
 

david starling

Well-known member
An aquarius moon in vedic and a pisces moon in western mean the same thing.

A rose by any other name, smells just as sweet. :sideways:

I've read the descriptions of 2 Vedic Moon-signs--VERY different for Cap and Aqua, and, both are in line with Tropical Moon in those Signs. The Vedic Aqua Moon wasn't much like the Tropical version of a Pisces Moon. Different sources, maybe?
 

david starling

Well-known member
A mile is not a "more correct form of measurement" than a kilometer :smile:
miles and kilometers are simply two of the many alternative ways of measuring distance
Similarly with VEDIC astrology and TROPICAL ASTROLOGY
these are two different methodologies of astrology

BRIEF VISUAL VIDEO EXPLANATION OF TROPICAL AND SIDEREAL
measurement
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=82p-DYgGFjI&feature=related

that's another great example of generalisation being so much fun
and yet so uneliable

because

"AIR moons" = Gemini, Libra, Aquarius

clearly a GEMINI Moon ruler is MERCURY
and since Mercury may be placed in any of twelve different SIGNS
as well as in any of twelve different houses

in aspects that differ from natal chart to natal chart
then
Gemini Moons are not identical regarding the handling of emotion

similarly a LIBRA Moon ruler is VENUS
and since Venus may be placed in any of twelve different SIGNS
as well as in any of twelve different houses
in aspects that differ from natal chart to natal chart
then
LIBRA Moons are not identical regarding the handling of emotion


AQUARIUS Moon ruler is SATURN
and since Saturn may be placed in any of twelve different SIGNS
as well as in any of twelve different houses

in aspects that differ from natal chart to natal chart
then
AQUARIUS Moons are not identical regarding the handling of emotion


"WATER moons" = Cancer, Scorpio, Pisces

clearly Moon ruler is in own domicile in Cancer
however a Cancer Moon may be found in any of twelve different houses
in aspect with planets that differ from natal chart to natal chart
CANCER Moons are therefore not identical regarding the handling of emotion


SCORPIO Moon ruler is MARS
and since Mars may be placed in any of twelve different SIGNS
as well as in any of twelve different houses
in aspects that differ from natal chart to natal chart
then
SCORPIO Moons are not identical regarding the handling of emotion


PISCES Moon ruler is JUPITER
and since Jupiter may be placed in any of twelve different SIGNS
as well as in any of twelve different houses
in aspects that differ from natal chart to natal chart
then
PISCES
Moons are not identical regarding the handling of emotion


The Sign a planet (including Sun and Moon) is in determines the Quality of its Expression.
 

JUPITERASC

Well-known member
The Sign a planet (including Sun and Moon) is in
determines the Quality of its Expression.
Example:
Those with Sun, Moon AQUARIUS 1st House are not all identical personalities, but differ :smile:

because

the quality of a planet's expression
is influenced by the SIGN location of that PLANET

and

SATURN ruler of AQUARIUS may be placed in any of twelve signs

and
SATURN ruler of AQUARIUS may be placed in any of twelve houses

hence
the differences
 

muchacho

Well-known member
Hi there :)
I have Capricorn sun, Aquarius Moon in Vedic astrology.
I have Aquarius sun, Pisces moon in Natal Astrology.
I'm just wondering how that would play out? Which one do you think it more correct? air and water moons are very different in the way they handle emotions.
Yes, they are very different, not compatible at all. The Aquarius Moon is very stable and aloof and not easily influenced by what's going on around, the Pisces Moon is very unstable and very emotional and soaks up what's going on around. The Pisces Moon is very easily brought to tears and you basically never see that with the Aquarius Moon. You have to decide for yourself which description fits best. But this should be an easy one.
 

sibylline

Well-known member
Hi there :)
I have Capricorn sun, Aquarius Moon in Vedic astrology.
I have Aquarius sun, Pisces moon in Natal Astrology.
I'm just wondering how that would play out? Which one do you think it more correct? air and water moons are very different in the way they handle emotions.

We don't want to make too many generalizations because even with the same Sun/Moon, things could shape up very differently depending on other factors in the chart. My brother is Aquarius Moon and I've seen him cry more in the past few years than my bf who is Pisces Moon. Neither of them are inclined to be detached or aloof, but my brother can more easily detach from emotions if they are running too high.

According to your chart you'd be Cap Sun conjunct Uranus, Aquarius Moon conjunct Mercury, Venus in Sag in Vedic. I know someone with these same placements in Western. He's friendly, very ambitious, a bit hotheaded (elevated Aries Mars square Sun), and sensitive to personal slights/proud. I highly doubt he'd take a name like "emotionalaquarius", however. Sounds more like your Pisces Moon/stellium.
 
Top