Hi Princess V.
If the Part of tragedy that you're referring to is that which is derived from , Asc. + Saturn - Sun, Then that is what I've known as the Part of Tragedy and Fatality.
I wrote something on this already in one of these threads on astrological parts in answer to Phoenix Venus' question on some matter of import to Her.
I'll see if I can't find it later on, it's real late and I had intended to get to you thread and post this eve, but it didn't work out as I had hoped.
So, I'm am going to attempt to convey the explanation in a very condensed form. I hope this works out... [I'm crossing my fingers, anyways]
I have found, to my own satisfaction, and to such a degree I might even say 'Complete'. The Part is about how the world will deem your life at it's closing.
If you'll allow me to use the allegorical here.
Let me first set the situation; We have to go back to ancient Greece in that there are only two type of plays written and performed on stage...either a 'Tragedy' or a 'Comedy' [if I wrong about that factually, well..let's just agree to say that's the fact for the sake of getting this explained...okay?]
Your life is a grand play, t's a 'Tragedy', written by a master hand and you are in the lead role.
The Part of Destiny is, just that, your own destiny, Who you were born to be ,as according to one of the 360 precepts of the degrees of the Zodiac symbolized so aptly by the Sabian Symbols produced by Elsie Wheeler and interpreted, defined and presented by Dane Rudhyar. [I have found no other set of degree symbols equal, let alone better, and as to the set known as the Sabian, no one to have equaled Dane in understanding, explaining, defining and presenting them.]. The Desc. of your chart axis is similar in a way, as it is stated to be the "WHERE-TO" destination of the "WHO" of the Asc. symbolically given by these symbols. One might even go so far as to say that the M.C. and I.C. are a bit similar as they represent the "HOW" and "WHY" of the chart axis symbolism and thus explain the process of "HOW" "WHO" is to get to WHERE-TO" and for the reason "WHY".
Getting back to this 'Play' that is a 'tragedy.
A "Play" is a story and this one in particular is the story of your life. The Part of Destiny [and, or if you wish, you can include part or all of what I just wrote of concerning the symbolism for the four axis points.] is your life story. This Part of Tragedy/Fatality is the 'Moral of the Story', conveyed symbolically through the Sabian Symbol found for the particular Zodiacal degree you find that Part to be in.
[Everyone, if you mention any of the Astrological Parts/Lots for the first time in a thread, could you all please give the formula it is derived from. Not everyone uses the same title given for some Parts and some have many titles, It does help a lot as it sometimes takes me awhile to figure out just which part you all are referring to...Thanks ptv]
As to the Part of Benevolence, I assume you are talking about the one derived from the formula, Asc. + Jupiter - Pluto.
If so, I can only say that I haven't worked with that Part except for a very small number of natal charts. This is a Part that includes Pluto in the formula and no one I know of has had a chance to really get a handle on them yet.
Except the following as for what i have found and am very positive they will stand to further inquiry.
Asc. + Moon - Pluto = Part of Racial Consciousness, or Race or Galvanization, as Pluto was all over the one for the zero hour USA natal chart during the Civil War from 1860 to 1865...yes, all those years in direct and again in retrograde.
Asc. + Pluto - Venus = Part of Libido [see my thread on Bill Clinton in the mundane sub-forum]
Asc. + Pluto - Saturn = Part of Organization [see my thread on Hillary Clinton as her' is conj. her M.C. and Saturn conjuncted that in the midst of Her Presidential campaign in 2007 {I think it was} and note that I use a chart based on a time no one else is working with. There's an uncertainty about the time she was born and I did a 'reading with the clairvoyant, Clarisse Conner, on the matter and what she saw as the time of birth and I saw from a chart produced from that, and for the reason why she explained it to be that time, both convinced me beyond a doubt...both to the time provided and that Clarisse is one dang fine, Clairvoyant. Clarisse really Rocks, at this stuff...truly.
Asc. + Pluto - Uranus = what some call the part of Radical Change but I prefer the term, Sudden Change. Richard Nixon's natal part was conj. his progressed charts I.C. the day he resigned. See my thread on Richard Nixon in the mundane sub forum and my thread on Obama Parts, that was in the mundane but got moved and hence buried in the Natal astrology-celebrity sub-forum, as I make reference to this part as to what I see coming up for Pres. Obama in early 2014 with His progressed natal chart.
This 'Part of Benevolence', as you identified it, I wrote in my thread, [in which I list every Part I know of, and is an ongoing project as it is ever increasing in number, here in the Degree Symbols sub forum , titled,] "Astrological Parts, Known and Unknown...a project" , the following; "Benevolence [which for the formula] ...[Asc +] Jupiter - Pluto...[seeing as how] ...Pluto is the Higher Octave of Mars [and as Asc. +] Jupiter - Mars = Discord this [title given title of Benevolence] seems erroneous. [and I also wrote] I surmise it to be something rather as to Destructive Philosophy, Destructive Growth, Destructive Gifts, {or possibly it might even be} Contrariness."
Hey ptv! I really like your analogy to the Greek theatre and each of our lives being a play that we are in the lead role. You are correct in that there was either Tragedy or Comedy (at least back in ancient Greece and Rome.) My boyfriend was an Honor Thespian throughout High School and actually has tattoos of the Mask for Tragedy on one of his wrists and the Mask for Comedy on the other. I also personally really like "The Divine Comedy" by Dante Alighieri.
Here is a really cool link on 'Comedy and Tragedy' ~
http://condor.depaul.edu/dsimpson/tlove/comic-tragic.html
For my part of Tragedy, I indeed used the formula: Asc + Saturn - Sun.
For that I got, Aquarius 19.41.
20 Aquarius
[ibid.]
"
PHASE 320: (AQUARIUS 20°): A LARGE WHITE DOVE BEARING A MESSAGE.
KEYNOTE: The answer of spiritual agencies to thorough, sustained and victorious individual efforts.
This concludes most significantly this series of five symbols. The individual who has gone courageously and with indomitable spirit through his crucial crisis receives, as it were, a deep spiritual blessing from the Soul-realm: "Mission accomplished. Peace be with you." And in this blessing a secret prophecy of what is yet to come may be seen by the perspicacious and spiritually sensitive mind of the recipient. Every real spiritual step a man takes in his development is the result of a victory over forces of inertia or destruction. The Divine is totally "present" in the heart of all true victories.
This is the fifth and last symbol of the sixty-fourth series. What the "message" is depends on the particular situation, but the white dove always signifies peace; at the very heart of this peace is the
CERTIFICATION of individual worth and victory."
Hopefully, mine is a Comedy!
"A comedy is a story of the rise in fortune of a sympathetic central character." As opposed to a Tragedy,
"Tragedy depicts the downfall of a basically good person through some fatal error or misjudgment, producing suffering and insight on the part of the protagonist and arousing pity and fear on the part of the audience." [taken from the link I provided above.]
Sorry for the confusion on the Part of Benevolence. The formula I used for that was: Asc + Jupiter - Mercury. It said it was the Part for: Benevolence, Assurance, Real Estate Investment. For That I got Aquarius 19.41 which is the 20th of Aquarius, the same for my Part of Tragedy.
I recalculated the formula for Benevolence that you gave me:
Asc + Jupiter - Pluto = Aries 11.6
12 Aries
[ibid.]
"
PHASE 12 (ARIES 12°): A TRIANGULARLY SHAPED FLIGHT OF WILD GEESE.
KEYNOTE: An idealistic reliance upon a mental image of universal order.
The wild goose is the mystical bird,
hamsa, of Hindu tradition. This word, which has recurred in various cultures (the
Hansa League of Germanic cities in the late Middle Ages, and
El Hanza, the founder of the occult Brotherhood of the Druzes in Lebanon, during the era of the Crusades), has always had at least an undertone of integration at an expansionistic level, spiritual or economic. The Hindu
hamsa was the symbol of man's transcendent soul. What previous interpretations of this Sabian symbol have failed to grasp is that the flight of geese presents not only a remarkably geometrical V-shape moving through the sky, but also that this flight is seasonal and therefore attuned to planetary rhythms. Thus, it symbolizes
cosmic order, in contrast with the social-political order within a nation which is represented by its ruler. It is order made visual on the background of the clear sky. It is a "celestial" type of order, even though it is earth-born birds which reveal it by their ability to keep their flight structured. The symbol therefore refers to the Soul-consciousness as visualized by the heaven-oriented mind. Yet this soul-consciousness can be called transcendent because it has not yet become "incarnated."
Because this is a second stage in the third five-fold sequence begun with Phase 11, we have to consider what it pictures
in contrast to the preceding symbol. A basic dualism of consciousness is thus suggested. We see arising a potential conflict between cosmic and social principles of order. The principle of
COSMIC ORDER polarizes the all-too-human reliance on the social concept of law and order."
I will continue on the next post to make it easier to read through . . .