tikana
Well-known member
And speaking as a moderator: this thread is teetering on the edge of breaking several rules. First of all, rudeness and attacking are NOT allowed; respect of other posters is REQUIRED at all times. There have been some borderline rude responses to people who have reasonably pointed out the problems with using horary for this kind of question.
Furthermore, posting other people's natal charts IS allowed if ONE of the following is true: you have their explicit permission to do so (which the OP doesn't appear to) OR you remove their name and birth information from the chart and do not share any identifying details. Since the natal chart posted has been anonymized, and no clearly identifying details have been shared, it meets the forum rules on that count. However, this is the horary section. Natal charts are NOT to be posted here unless there's a clear connection being made between a natal chart and the horary.
And that says nothing about the ethics of posting someone else's natal chart. It's not fair to ask astrological questions about someone who's not participating in the conversation and has not consented to having questions asked about them. Furthermore, interpreting a birth chart is quite subjective. Every bit of it has multiple possible manifestations, only some of which will be true of the native. It's impossible to determine which of the many possible manifestations apply without the native present to affirm or contradict. And the chart does NOT show what choices the native has made in their life. Whether this person has a criminal career or just a very secretive but perfectly legal one, the astrological markers would be the same.
Osamenor
I have a few griefs over the question.
1. if the querent is not in direct danger from the quested, querent is not minding her own business (later asce usually yields mind your own business) Primary why I do not wanna answer the question I dont know the intent or how will the answers be used. Plus this is 2nd question from the querent about mafia/murder connection. Makes you really wonder what is going on.
2. as you pointed out, natal chart does not "make" a person do this or that.
3. natal chart was posted but it was deleted (I think you guys took it down - good) .. no permission do not post the chart
4. If there is nothing you can personally affect a situation, dont ask. (i am not talking about you just saying in general. Lets say he is a mafioso murderer - then what?
tik
Last edited: