(Following includes statements not generally accepted in conventional astrological delineation)
Both charts are strong: Capricorn on asc indicating serious matters, potential for solid and longer term commitments; your significator, Saturn, in both charts in its exaltation degrees and in the 10th (whole sign) house, which also places you (Saturn) in the house of career (the 10th), another auspicious indication
-Chart 1 (women in general chart) is slightly stronger than Chart 2: in Chart 1 Moon is approaching Cazimi, with also Sun and Part of Fortune posited in the first house AND ALL 3 ARE IN THE ELEVATED 13TH DEGREE of Capricorn.
-Chart 2 (eating disorder) is strong because Moon is closer to Cazimi than in Chart 1, both Moon and Sun are in the elevated 13th degree of Capricorn, and POF is also in the first house, however in this chart the POF is not in the elevated degree as it is in Chart 1, so Chart 2, while strong, is not quite as strong as Chart 1.
Also Chart 1 has the highly benefic star Pelagus (aka "Nunki") longitudinally conjunct the ascending degree; Chart 2 also has a fortunate star on the ascending degree, Dheneb, but this star is not quite as benefic as Pelagus (see constellationsofwords.com for more information regarding these stars)