Not if the dwarf planet is in 12th
by the way 4th house is not 12th house topic
So this makes sense to me. At the same time it's impossible to deny the uranian bent modern astrology takes. As astrologers we cast charts at the drop of a hat with our computers, often without even looking at the sky, maybe situating ourselves within an ocean of social epistemologies rather than consciousness itself. Interpretations are available to the masses, and masses too can become astrologers the same way I did, with a subscription to a free chart-casting service. Discussing here is an 11th house activity.
So this makes sense to me. At the same time it's impossible to deny the uranian bent modern astrology takes. As astrologers we cast charts at the drop of a hat with our computers, often without even looking at the sky, maybe situating ourselves within an ocean of social epistemologies rather than consciousness itself. Interpretations are available to the masses, and masses too can become astrologers the same way I did, with a subscription to a free chart-casting service. Discussing here is an 11th house activity.
Good point, well madeActually, that was a reply to a Thread-worthy question; since I revealed that Venus is in Aquarius in H12,
it was relevant to ask the House and Sign location of the native Ruler of the Sign Aquarius.
The overall situation of the Ruler of the 12th House Sign is a "12th house topic"[IMO].
Traditionally, my reply would have been "(day ruler) Saturn in Leo in H6";
in which case the 6th House is also included in this H12 discussion,
as it relates to H12.
since Traditionally
Since, IMO, H12 is the House of Imaginations,
it is the only House where Pluto can imagine himself big enough and bright enough to be included as a ruling-Planet by even Traditional standards.
distance as well as the tiny size of dwarf planetsAlso, since Pluto is "hidden" from view
due to its distance from the Earth,
it's a good fit for H12!
That celestial object is certainly a planet
By the same token, so is Neptune.
Aquarius ruling 12thYou see the signs where you have 12th (example: aquarius-pisces).
Then you search in the chart where you have Saturn (rule aquarius) and Jupiter (rule pisces).
The place where they are, would mean the first channel for this house.
Example: you have a Jupiter-Saturn conjunction in the X.
One of the best signification now in my mind be that of triumph (X house) over secret enemies (12th).
Aquarius ruling 12th
with a Jupiter-Saturn conjunction in 10th house
implies Pisces Ascendant
and therefore a Jupiter-Saturn conjunction in Sagittarius
Sagittarius is the domicile of Jupiter
and so in this particular case Saturn is not in own domicile
and therefore weakened
Jupiter Saturn conjunction has a variable effect
dependent on the SIGN
as well as the house location
however obviously a chart of the theoretical example mentioned
is required in order to assess
Easier to assess by viewing the natal chartTotally OT but I cannot post 'thanks' anywhere, when I click the button it just disappears.
Very much appreciating this conversation!
I often wonder what H12 Saturn would feel like in a different chart.
Mine is square H3 Sun and dispositors of NN and SN, and my NN is also in 12th.
My sibling [H3] also has H12 Saturn but in the same sign as Asc, & has a lot of outward success (NN in 10th)
in one of those very typical 12th house professions.
But his Saturn squares H3 Venus and despite being extremely attractive and kind he is single.
Can't help but feel somehow responsible for that!
Why "ouch" for Libra Saturn in joy in 12th house?true, his H12 Saturn is in Libra.. so exalted AND in its house of joy.. Ouch, no?
natal chart shows that only five minutes earlier, ascendant was Virgo
I have attached my own chart
Thank you
Would be simpler to comment by viewing your siblings chartYes, I'm certain of libra rising ;-)
Why 'ouch' to my sibling's 12H Saturn in Libra (squaring Venus the chart ruler)?
Probably because my own impression of a H12 Saturn is colored by its square to Merc/Sun/Neptune in my own chart.
It sounds like intense inner conflict.
And - as someone pointed out earlier in the thread
- even a well placed Saturn is always going to be Saturn, and not a second Jupiter.
Reading you here it seems like there are two sides, one that says its "bad bad, terribly bad", and the other one lacks one "bad" in the previous sentence. As that being further discussed, tell us your oppinion whether there Is a way to work on it, how to minimise the effect of "badness" for that "joyous" placement. Because it doesn't seem to be good to be the owner of one right now
[/COLOR]
I welcome any comment you have on making lemonade from a 12H Saturn square in my own chart, but regretfully do not have permission to post sibling chart