Either way ET, the houses have to be ignored in your chart analyses.....as these are valid only if you have an accurate birthtime.
The Moon moves around 1 degree every two hours.......So, if this person was indeed born around 5.00 am, a chart based upon that time would give an accurate Moon location......whereas a Noon/12pm chart would give a Moon position that was 3+ degrees later.....Thus, a 5.00am chart is "better" than a Noon Chart if the person is sure about the approximate birthtime.
Whichever chart you use though, the important thing is to not use any information that cannot be relied upon....(Houses in both charts, and the Moon degree in the Noon Chart)
[Note : The Natural Zodiac always exerts a subtle influence on every individual.......So, valid house information sometimes can be gleaned from this]
EJ