So what is the purpose of traditional astrology in today’s world?

JUPITERASC

Well-known member
Without Modernist astrology,
Traditionalist astrology would have practically faded away.
WITHOUT TRADITIONAL ASTROLOGY MODERNIST ASTROLOGY WOULDN'T EXIST
and the flimsy statement "...practically faded away..."
is of no consequence

since clearly

Traditional astrology is increasing in popularity
so obviously NOT faded away :smile:

and notice

Traditional astrological techniques are the indispensable foundation stone
on which modernist astrology is completely dependent
and
without traditional astrology, modernistic astrology cannot exist


.
 

JUPITERASC

Well-known member
It was the Modernists who restored Traditionalism.
Traditional astrology has always been practised
despite attempts by Modernistic astrologers to rebrand it
i.e.

Modernistic astrologers attempted to pass off Traditional method
as Modernistic
using rebranding as earlier stated - example Modernistic SOLAR RETURN
is in fact and has always been the Traditional SOLAR REVOLUTION :smile:


.
 

JUPITERASC

Well-known member
- I too started (back in the early 1960s) as a Modernist
because

back then Traditional (Western) astrology had not yet been reborn.
Nevertheless you utilised Traditional methods :smile:
even if self styled as Modernistic astrologer

Traditional Western method was presented as modernistic



.
 

david starling

Well-known member
Modern vehicles are based on ancient vehicles. They still refer to "Horse Power" as a unit of measurement.

The wheel was first introduced in the Tigris Euphrates prior to 3100 B.C.E. Nearly all land vehicles today rely on wheels, which were invented so long ago.

"Traditional" astrology as a stand-alone term, could mean ancient Egyptian, Babylonian, or Chinese methods, as well as Hellenistic and Persian.

Everything's gotta start somewhere!
 
Last edited:

JUPITERASC

Well-known member
Modern vehicles are based on ancient vehicles.
They still refer to "Horse Power" as a unit of measurement.
The wheel was first introduced in the Tigris Euphrates prior to 3100 B.C.E.
Nearly all land vehicles today rely on wheels, which were invented so long ago. "Traditional" astrology as a stand-alone term, could mean ancient Egyptian, Babylonian,
or Chinese methods, as well as Hellenistic and Persian.
Everything's gotta start somewhere!
Modernistic SOLAR RETURN is rebranded Traditional SOLAR REVOLUTION :smile:


.
 

JUPITERASC

Well-known member
Purely Traditional is a protected version of astrology

as it's now being practiced by most astrologers.
Modernistic astrology depends on Traditional method
and cannot function without Traditional

in contrast

Traditional astrology is separate and independent of Modernistic


for example as previously stated

this thread is on our Traditional board, separate from other boards :smile:

and so on ad infinitum
Q.E.D.




.
 
Top