Is Pluto an astrological planet?

JUPITERASC

Well-known member
this is a stupid topic like you trying to prove that pluto is not an astrological planet
ive seen maney charts and it is just amazing how pluto influence the chart
IF pluto IS an astrological planet
then so are these
and as many as ten thousand other dwarf planets :smile:

dwarf-planet-sizes.png
 

JUPITERASC

Well-known member
Pluto is an
astronomical planet as well ..
That's wishful thinking :smile:
the fact is that astronomically speaking

the reason pluto is an astronomical dwarf planet
is
because
there are multiple objects similar in size and mass to pluto
that are all in the same orbit as pluto
and until pluto crashes into these objects and then absorbs them after the collision
pluto will remain an astronomical dwarf planet
 

lauren2x

Well-known member
That's wishful thinking :smile:
the fact is that astronomically speaking

the reason pluto is an astronomical dwarf planet
is
because
there are multiple objects similar in size and mass to pluto
that are all in the same orbit as pluto
and until pluto crashes into these objects and then absorbs them after the collision
pluto will remain an astronomical dwarf planet

okay it is an astronomical dwarf planet but it's influence is just like the influence of jupiter sun moon mars neptune uranus .... :)
 

JUPITERASC

Well-known member

okay it is an astronomical dwarf planet

but it's influence is just like the influence of jupiter sun moon mars neptune uranus ....
:)
all those planets you mentioned are astronomical planets as well as astrological planets :smile:
but not dwarf planet pluto which was mistakenly presented as a planet
 

JUPITERASC

Well-known member
and this is your evidence that jupiter has links to luck XD
the rationale of this thread is
to discuss whether or not dwarf planet pluto is an astrological planet or not
I simply responded to your comment
that Jupiter is an astrological planet as well as an astronomical planet :smile:
in direct contrast with dwarf planet pluto which is most definitely not an astronomical planet

there is also the fact that
there is a dwarf planet bigger than dwarf planet pluto
yet no one is demanding dwarf planet ERIS to be treated as 'an astrological planet'

 

lauren2x

Well-known member
the rationale of this thread is
to discuss whether or not dwarf planet pluto is an astrological planet or not
I simply responded to your comment
that Jupiter is an astrological planet as well as an astronomical planet :smile:
in direct contrast with dwarf planet pluto which is most definitely not an astronomical planet

there is also the fact that
there is a dwarf planet bigger than dwarf planet pluto
yet no one is demanding dwarf planet ERIS to be treated as 'an astrological planet'


pluto is bigger then eris
[deleted attacking comment - Moderator]
 
Last edited by a moderator:

waybread

Well-known member
JA,Modern astrologers are coming around to the conviction that an astronomical dwarf planet is still an astrological planet. End of story?

That you don't think Pluto has anything to do with healing confirms my suspicion that you actually do not know how Pluto works astrologically. Please read up on Pluto and healing.

Please also read Henry Seltzer's new book on astrological Eris.

We live in wonderful times, with new astrological vistas ahead of us, as the trans-Neptunians become better understood.

JA, I notice that you post a lot, at all times of day. Could it be that you are at home a lot, and don't circulate much in society? You seem offended at the notion of so many asteroids and trans-Neptunians out there. Do you find so much unknown diversity to be bewildering or threatening in some way? Does a predictable and limiting structure seem important to you?

Lauren, Eris does have at least one moon, called Dysnomia.
 
Last edited:

JUPITERASC

Well-known member

pluto is bigger then eris
You have been misinformed

Ja please have some knoweldge
and then come and talk
if you know nothing dont talk
:)
Practice what you preach :smile:

'.....Eris is the most-massive and second-largesthttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eris_(dwarf_planet)#cite_note-footnoteI-18 dwarf planet known in the Solar System.

It is the ninth-most-massive body known to directly orbit the Sun


Eris is 27% more massive than dwarf planet pluto,

though pluto is slightly larger by volume. Eris's mass is about 0.27% of the Earth's mass....'https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eris_(dwarf_planet)#cite_note-Brown_Schaller_2007-12https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eris_(dwarf_planet)#cite_note-070614_eris_mass-20
 

lauren2x

Well-known member
You have been misinformed


Practice what you preach :smile:

'.....Eris is the most-massive and second-largesthttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eris_(dwarf_planet)#cite_note-footnoteI-18 dwarf planet known in the Solar System.

It is the ninth-most-massive body known to directly orbit the Sun


Eris is 27% more massive than dwarf planet pluto,

though pluto is slightly larger by volume. Eris's mass is about 0.27% of the Earth's mass....'https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eris_(dwarf_planet)#cite_note-Brown_Schaller_2007-12https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eris_(dwarf_planet)#cite_note-070614_eris_mass-20

science again i wonder why do you want so badly to prove that pluto is not planet or astrological planet .
 

JUPITERASC

Well-known member
science again
i wonder why do you want so badly to prove that pluto is not planet or astrological planet .

We just disagree
Many astrologers disagree
It's not unusual :smile:
The thread discussion is simply regarding whether pluto is or is not an astrological planet
we already proved that dwarf planet pluto is not an astronomical planet
and that dwarf planet ERIS is larger than pluto
yet strangely no one has a response regarding
the lack of demand to make ERIS an astrological planet
not to mention all the other dwarf planets
 

lauren2x

Well-known member

We just disagree
Many astrologers disagree
It's not unusual :smile:
The thread discussion is simply regarding whether pluto is or is not an astrological planet
we already proved that dwarf planet pluto is not an astronomical planet
and that dwarf planet ERIS is larger than pluto
yet strangely no one has a response regarding
the lack of demand to make ERIS an astrological planet
not to mention all the other dwarf planets

maney astrologyers *agree* that pluto is an astrological planet FEW astrologers disagree and ALL the people feel pluto energy except you
 

JUPITERASC

Well-known member
maney astrologyers *agree* that pluto is an astrological planet
FEW astrologers disagree
and ALL the people feel pluto energy except you
That is misinformed and in any event, the discussion does not concern dwarf planet pluto's alleged 'enegy'
but whether or not pluto can be considered an astrological planet
even if it is not an astronomical planet
and
also given that dwarf planet Eris is bigger than dwarf planet pluto
it makes no sense that no one is questioning why Eris is not an astrological planet as well :smile:
 

lauren2x

Well-known member
That is misinformed and in any event, the discussion does not concern dwarf planet pluto's alleged 'enegy'
but whether or not pluto can be considered an astrological planet
even if it is not an astronomical planet
and
also given that dwarf planet Eris is bigger than dwarf planet pluto
it makes no sense that no one is questioning why Eris is not an astrological planet as well :smile:

because astrology is not science
 
Last edited:
Top