23
Well-known member
Hi there
I'm very new to horary astrology and I'd like someone to please have a look at to see if I have done this right. It's a friend's questions and I've already given her my reading, just hoping I have done it right. She has given me permission to put her chart and questions on here and is eagerly looking forward to seeing what others say.
She asks the very broad question of "Will I have a family with X"? I took that to encompass more than just family (4th house) but also 5th house (children) and 7th (relationship) based on the explanation she gave after the question. She drew the chart up herself so there is no need to turn the chart.
She is represented by the ASC (Sag) and its ruler, Jupiter in Aries/5th as well as Moon in Gemini/7th. The ruler of the hour is Mercury. Jupiter and Mercury are not of the same nature. There is an applying trine but it is out of aspect between Jupiter and Mercury. I said it was wonky and strictly, you couldn't ask this question because of this but because they are in applying trine I said we should proceed with caution.
There is no other strictures stopping this question of the other questions apart from possibly from disparate natures of ASC/ASC ruler and hour ruler.
1. Relationship - he is represented by Mercury, 7th house ruler.
Because of the above information, due to an applying trine, they could have a relationship in the future. Jupiter in Term, Mercury Peregrine. Answer: yes.
(She is more keen than him)
2. Family (as in functioning family unit).
Ruler of the 4th house (which represents family) is in Aquarius, ruler Saturn. Saturn and Jupiter make an out of aspect opposition. However they will perfect the opposition as Jupiter will go Rx, applying opposition. Answer I gave her was "no". Also I said to her that oppositions (more than squares) indicate a "no" answer as well as Saturn being a natural obstruction despite Saturn's special role here. Uranus nearby (not a ruler of anything in horary) still rules surprises and instability so this also adds instability.
(Jupiter in Term, Saturn in Term and when opposition perfected, Jupiter domicile (night ruler), Saturn exalted and in term. How do you deal with the planets strengthening and in opposition. Family stronger than her, so it won't happen?).
3. Children.
I don't know how to approach this question. The ruler of her (ASC) and children (5th) is both Jupiter. However, based on the explanation I gave for "family" (Saturn opposition and Uranus), the answer will be "no" (then I qualified it as said she might get pregnant unexpectedly and then lose it or something, final result of negative).
Then I assume that she was strictly Moon and Jupiter only represented children. There was no aspect between them. Moon had long separated from Jupiter in a sextile. Again no.
Here, which signifactors do I use for her is Jupiter represents both her and children and also what does it mean if there is the same significator for two houses that you are comparing against for an horary (for example, the above where there is no aspect to Saturn (or Uranus))? Does that normally mean "yes"?
I didn't know how to deal with this.
Thanks in advance and looking forward to seeing what you can say about this!
I'm very new to horary astrology and I'd like someone to please have a look at to see if I have done this right. It's a friend's questions and I've already given her my reading, just hoping I have done it right. She has given me permission to put her chart and questions on here and is eagerly looking forward to seeing what others say.
She asks the very broad question of "Will I have a family with X"? I took that to encompass more than just family (4th house) but also 5th house (children) and 7th (relationship) based on the explanation she gave after the question. She drew the chart up herself so there is no need to turn the chart.
She is represented by the ASC (Sag) and its ruler, Jupiter in Aries/5th as well as Moon in Gemini/7th. The ruler of the hour is Mercury. Jupiter and Mercury are not of the same nature. There is an applying trine but it is out of aspect between Jupiter and Mercury. I said it was wonky and strictly, you couldn't ask this question because of this but because they are in applying trine I said we should proceed with caution.
There is no other strictures stopping this question of the other questions apart from possibly from disparate natures of ASC/ASC ruler and hour ruler.
1. Relationship - he is represented by Mercury, 7th house ruler.
Because of the above information, due to an applying trine, they could have a relationship in the future. Jupiter in Term, Mercury Peregrine. Answer: yes.
(She is more keen than him)
2. Family (as in functioning family unit).
Ruler of the 4th house (which represents family) is in Aquarius, ruler Saturn. Saturn and Jupiter make an out of aspect opposition. However they will perfect the opposition as Jupiter will go Rx, applying opposition. Answer I gave her was "no". Also I said to her that oppositions (more than squares) indicate a "no" answer as well as Saturn being a natural obstruction despite Saturn's special role here. Uranus nearby (not a ruler of anything in horary) still rules surprises and instability so this also adds instability.
(Jupiter in Term, Saturn in Term and when opposition perfected, Jupiter domicile (night ruler), Saturn exalted and in term. How do you deal with the planets strengthening and in opposition. Family stronger than her, so it won't happen?).
3. Children.
I don't know how to approach this question. The ruler of her (ASC) and children (5th) is both Jupiter. However, based on the explanation I gave for "family" (Saturn opposition and Uranus), the answer will be "no" (then I qualified it as said she might get pregnant unexpectedly and then lose it or something, final result of negative).
Then I assume that she was strictly Moon and Jupiter only represented children. There was no aspect between them. Moon had long separated from Jupiter in a sextile. Again no.
Here, which signifactors do I use for her is Jupiter represents both her and children and also what does it mean if there is the same significator for two houses that you are comparing against for an horary (for example, the above where there is no aspect to Saturn (or Uranus))? Does that normally mean "yes"?
I didn't know how to deal with this.
Thanks in advance and looking forward to seeing what you can say about this!
Last edited: