When you look at the ascendant or a planet you will always have to look at the final dispositor cause the final dispositor in a chart will always have the final say as the actual boss telling what the rest of the planets can do or not to do. A person appearance is a product and result of physical and mental health and of course his or her food consumption. It is impossible to ask an anorexic to be curvy and in her case this extreme water element off balance manifested in her mental state instead of manifesting physically as curves cause she hate it and by all mean eliminated this natural occurrence.
AHAHAHAHHAHAHAHA yeah good point!
Karen Carpenter's rising final depositor would be Saturn or Mercury? Either way, both those planets HATE fleshiness.
As for Chloe... her final Asc depositor is Mars. Mars doesn't want to have bulk or extra weight since he cannot function optimally if he's weighed down by his own body so I can see why she stays so thin.
I'm just not convinced that water dominant charts gives curvy females. If I saw Karla's chart without seeing her pics, I would have said point blank, "this is a fat chick." Upon seeing her pictures, I know that I'm right.