Yes, but this must then include all questions about other persons like "Is my ex involved with someone else?" or " Does our postman cheat on his wife?". Indeed this is not the querents business but such questions are nevertheless answered in this forum. I think we agree with that questions about mortality and murder are too delicate and the astrologer have toexample with reference to
the morality of the following horary question
highlighting the following:
'....It's not fair to ask astrological questions
about someone who's not participating in the conversation
and has not consented to having questions asked about them...'
in any event the individual has been deprived of their rights
to defend themselves from defamatory inferences
from people whose motives are unknown
decide subjectively , depents on the intentions and context of the querent if he wants to answer the question or not. In the example she could indeed ask and get an answer ...the answer is lying in the chart...but I still wonder what she will do with it. Especially, what is if the astrologer gives the wrong answer but the querent relies on it?! the effects are too dangerous in such cases.