I think Archergirl is right...maybe we're not specifying what we all view as 'romantic'...Though I feel most people on this thread are associating romance with flower,poetry,soft music,staring at stars on a beautiful summer night...the typical Libra/Pisces thing.
I have Venus in Aries,4th house.I never liked flowers,they die very soon.Rings and jewelry,they're too expensive.Stuffed animals,my Arian Moon can't get enough of them
And candies,ohhh,chocolate is my downfall.But most of all,I love poetry and love letters...very elaborate love letters,where people specify exacly what they like about me and what they feel about our relationship.I have never received one though...