david starling
Well-known member
Regarding the entirety of the Human species, those Humans who know all Humans are idiots, are wiser than all of the Humans who think of themselves as geniuses.
Last edited:
Great post!
I would like to add, the problem is not just rapid development of human intelligence but also the lack of intelligence. We humans like to think about ourselves that we are "the absolute masters of Earth", "the only intelligent species". This is far from true. Whoever designed humans, designed them to be just intelligent enough to perform certain tasks but not intelligent enough to challenge the designers. Humans were designed to be the race of primitive slaves.
Our intelligence is not much greater than intelligence of other animals, probably we are not even the most intelligent species on the planet.
For example, orangutan Sandy scored 75 on IQ test live on TV, beating some of human competitors. Gorilla Koko scored between 70-90 on IQ tests. It is believed that elephants maintain 3D map of all places they ever visited in their life in their memory. This map is even updated with new information obtained through communication with other elephants. Chimps beat humans regularly in computer memory games. Dolphins, who are the most intelligent species on the planet IMO, can understand human language but we cannot understand theirs. And so on....
For all we know, the lowest threshold of what is called intelligence elsewhere in the universe could be IQ 1000 or IQ 2000. And we humans, with our average IQ 100 love to brag how intelligent we are. If we ever encounter some really intelligent species, with say IQ 2000, we would be nothing more than exotic animal to them, a ZOO specimen (but they probably don't have such barbaric concept as ZOO).
Considering that we are not that intelligent as we believe we are, our current situation is not much different than bunch of chimps sitting in front of red nuclear button and pondering whether to press it.
Frankly, I wouldn't rate humanity's chances too high.
Hippies had to do a lot of drugs to think Saturn's age would be great.
I believe it's very important to always consider intelligence as a multi-faceted concept. "Intelligent" is often a "catch-all" word for very different types of capabilities, talents, aptitudes, perceptions, etc. I'm a strong advocate of the multiple intelligence theory - which I personally believe is "fact" after teaching all kinds of students and pets for over 30 years. Individuals - no matter what species - can be "very smart" in very different ways.Our intelligence is not much greater than intelligence of other animals, probably we are not even the most intelligent species on the planet.
Amen, brother! I could not have said it better! The great French writer, Gustave Flaubert, wrote: "The Earth has limits, but human stupidity is infinite." Einstein is reputed to have said something very similar.Regarding the entirety of the Human species, those Humans who know all Humans are idiots, are wiser than all of the Humans who think of themselves as geniuses.
Love them as I do, we still must accept that neither a dolphin nor a gorilla could ever build architectural wonders like the Pyramids, the Eiffel Tower, or the Great Wall of China, nor keep detailed inscribed records for posterity, nor create anything like a laptop computer (or even electricity) - and certainly nothing like Artificial Intelligence. Humans still have a clear advantage in cold logical-mathematical intelligence. BUT that is only one intelligence out of NINE.
I will definitely concede that it is quite possible that dolphins have linguistic/communicative intelligence that may well be quite superior to that of humans - however, that is a different intelligence of the nine - but not one to be underrated! It is a different intelligence from the type that I believe humans still dominate - cold, hard technical/logical/mathematical intelligence (because this one was hard-wired into humans).
Unfortunately, due to the limitations of dolphin anatomy, we may never know to what degree they possess or could employ this latter intelligence - which has actually done great harm to the Earth in so many ways, from devastating weaponry to overwhelming pollution and species extinction.
Dolphins are not likely to ever put satellites into orbit, build underwater cities to protect themselves, or invent equipment that will permit them to navigate on land among us as we do underwater among them. That all involves the one intelligence that most obsesses mankind, coupled with his more complex and capable anatomy. (That's why a hominid species was singled out for the "explosive brain evolution".)
But if you allow for transmigratory evolution (which I scandalously do), these dolphins may be the brilliant citizens of a new and brighter Dwapara Yuga and mature Age of Aquarius that values all intelligences equally.
PS: The one "friend" I had who was a true genius (highest IQ score I'd ever seen) completely sabotaged his own life. He was intellectually arrogant, and he seemed to have no interpersonal, intrapersonal, or existential intelligences...and oddly enough was deficient in linguistic intelligence as well - he insisted on using bizarre mispronunciations, malapropisms. and had no sense of tact.
In fact he was frighteningly vengeful. He managed to alienate everyone, was thrown out of the honors program, wasted all his money recklessly. He had no musical talent whatsoever, threw trash out the window of the car, and believed there was nothing beyond this material world. He was overweight and clumsy. He had little that one might call "wisdom".
In fact, he lacked every intelligence above except the logical-mathematical, in which he excelled. He could figure out a mind-busting logic puzzle or solve the most difficult calculus problem faster than anyone I knew. And so what good did having that one great intelligence do him? Nothing. His was a tragically wasted life...a forerunner of what is to come, I believe.
I believe it's very important to always consider intelligence as a multi-faceted concept. "Intelligent" is often a "catch-all" word for very different types of capabilities, talents, aptitudes, perceptions, etc. I'm a strong advocate of the multiple intelligence theory - which I personally believe is "fact" after teaching all kinds of students and pets for over 30 years. Individuals - no matter what species - can be "very smart" in very different ways.
There are about nine intelligences (give or take) that have been recognized by those who have observed them in action for many years (as I have). Here's a chart that I find a basically satisfactory breakdown of "intelligences":
Whoever (or whatever) engineered the scientifically confirmed "explosive evolution" ("tumorous growth") of the cerebral cortex in the Pleistocene, which resulted in rapidly turning certain hominids into homo sapiens, obviously wanted to accelerate the "logical-mathematical" factor foremost, with "linguistic", "bodily-kinesthetic" and "spatial" probably close behind, as these intelligences would be the most practical to the "engineers" - good traits to have in groups of servants, workers and builders. It seems to me that the least important intelligences were the "interpersonal", "naturalist", 'intrapersonal" and "existential". (E.g., too much "intrapersonal" or "existential" intelligence would have made the servants question why they should unquestioningly serve their masters. Very inconvenient.)
Fortunately, these neglected intelligences grew on their own without manipulation in just enough people to keep civilization from being totally cold, unfair, cruel, and destructive - though it often comes very close to that...closer every day now....
A mitigating "logical" concept has been that of "enlightened self-interest" - i.e., making token efforts to show the masses that your pathologically avaricious trillionaire self is sometimes actually "generous" and "caring" - and hopefully they won't threaten you. The great concern I have is that more and more humans are falling for that gambit, as existential, intrapersonal,and interpersonal intelligences appear to be weakening rapidly - and more and more of humanity accepts "greed is good", "war is peace", and other nightmarish Orwellian tropes. But all this was prophesied long ago as inevitable during the climax and collapse of Kali Yuga.
Love them as I do, we still must accept that neither a dolphin nor a gorilla could ever build architectural wonders like the Pyramids, the Eiffel Tower, or the Great Wall of China, nor keep detailed inscribed records for posterity, nor create anything like a laptop computer (or even electricity) - and certainly nothing like Artificial Intelligence. Humans still have a clear advantage in cold logical-mathematical intelligence. BUT that is only one intelligence out of NINE.
At the same time, dolphins and gorillas have interpersonal and naturalist intelligences that make those of humankind in general seem savagely primitive. These two intelligences were not deliberately programmed into homo sapiens. Just look at the calamities throughout the world today, then think back to the Roman Colosseum, the Inquisitions, the Nazis, the oil industries, plastics choking our oceans, your daily news today...ad infinitum.
Much to our shame, dolphins and gorillas stay in mutually supportive groups, welcome others into their clans, protect each other, show genuine concern, even for human beings! And they would never stupidly destroy their own environment as humankind has been doing for ages.
Amen, brother! I could not have said it better! The great French writer, Gustave Flaubert, wrote: "The Earth has limits, but human stupidity is infinite." Einstein is reputed to have said something very similar.
I do agree that it is very probable that dolphins have linguistic/communicative (even historical) intelligence that is clearly (maybe vastly) superior to that of humans - in ways that we can't even comprehend yet. And it already seems self-evident that dolphins' interpersonal, naturalist, and spatial (their echo-location) intelligences are far superior to humans'. So it appears that dolphins already exceed homo sapiens in at least four of the nine intelligences above.
However, I still think that humans continue to dominate in cold, hard technical/logical/mathematical intelligence. At least tangibly. This intelligence has been hard-wired into humans. And it is one which - operating without sufficient intelligence in the other areas - has done the greatest harm to the Earth in endless ways - devastating warfare, dangerous pollution, unnatural extinctions, egregious income/power inequality....
Due to the limitations of dolphin anatomy, we may never know to what degree they possess this intelligence (which I know they have) or how they would employ it. This intelligence is not evil in itself - the evil is in its application. How would dolphins use it if they could...something to ponder.
Sadly, dolphins are not likely to reverse the destruction of our oceans, build underwater cities or submarines to protect themselves, or invent equipment that will permit them to navigate on land among us as we do underwater among them.
All of that first requires the one intelligence that obsesses and possesses homo sapiens the most, which is the only species that can fully wield it, given the more intricate, adaptable anatomy of human beings. That's why a hominid species was singled out for the "explosive brain evolution".
I can't concur with what you write here."Cold, hard technical/logical/mathematical intelligence" would be the problem solving capacity and dolphins have far superior problem solving capacity in comparison to humans (in addition to other types of intelligence where dolphins are also superior).
To start with your second statement, I fully agree - we certainly ARE their main problem. But in regard to your first statement:It's just that dolphins don't have that many problems to solve. We are their main problem.
I can't concur with what you write here.
One, it is now recognized that every type of intelligence involves problem-solving capability. And I am convinced after 30+ years of teaching that that is absolutely valid.
I should have warned you about the many amateurish descriptions of "types of intelligence" online which are just poor paraphrases of the original flawed, inchoate hypothesis first proposed over 40 years ago. Any description of logical-mathematical intelligence as merely "problem- solving capability" is nonsense - since problem-solving capability is an essential part of every other type of intelligence as well.
However, all the above are not even close to the logical-mathematical intelligence required for figuring out the incredible complexities of astrology/astronomy, nor for Newton's Principia Mathematica or his invention of calculus, nor for discovering quantum mechanics and proving quantum entanglement, nor for landing rovers on Mars and controlling their movements from 140,000,000 miles away.
But it is suggested that dolphins could do any of this if they just had problems to solve?
...instead of one overpowering one in a pathological, "tumorous" brain, one that coldly quantifies child causualties like a game score, calmly hypothesizes how many will die from starvation, scientifically calculates how soon many species will become extinct, analyzes with fascination just how incredibly wide the gap between the rich and the poor has/will become, examines with great interest the effects of toxins on fellow beings, excitedly experiments with a newly invented technology threat (like the latest one that encourages us to put glue on our pizza, rocks in our stomachs, and to jump off a bridge if we're depressed), and builds incredibly useful killer drones and invaluable devices that will spy on your every move.
This old thread is now back on track, The Ugly Side of the Age of Aquarius. So perhaps this is where this old thread should die. The warning has been more more than sounded - despite the many tangents. But the greater the attempt to show reality, the more reality is devastating. It serves no beneficent purpose. It may take a few hundred years before there is any rebirth of our civilization. Denial may be far preferable at this time. Some are already great masters of it.
One thing I have noticed is that the creatures of earth, all have language, that differ from each other, but is understood by all of them. We are the ones that don’t understand them.I believe it's very important to always consider intelligence as a multi-faceted concept. "Intelligent" is often a "catch-all" word for very different types of capabilities, talents, aptitudes, perceptions, etc. I'm a strong advocate of the multiple intelligence theory - which I personally believe is "fact" after teaching all kinds of students and pets for over 30 years. Individuals - no matter what species - can be "very smart" in very different ways.
There are about nine intelligences (give or take) that have been recognized by those who have observed them in action for many years (as I have). Here's a chart that I find a basically satisfactory breakdown of "intelligences":
Whoever (or whatever) engineered the scientifically confirmed "explosive evolution" ("tumorous growth") of the cerebral cortex in the Pleistocene, which resulted in rapidly turning certain hominids into homo sapiens, obviously wanted to accelerate the "logical-mathematical" factor foremost, with "linguistic", "bodily-kinesthetic" and "spatial" probably close behind, as these intelligences would be the most practical to the "engineers" - good traits to have in groups of servants, workers and builders. It seems to me that the least important intelligences were the "interpersonal", "naturalist", 'intrapersonal" and "existential". (E.g., too much "intrapersonal" or "existential" intelligence would have made the servants question why they should unquestioningly serve their masters. Very inconvenient.)
Fortunately, these neglected intelligences grew on their own without manipulation in just enough people to keep civilization from being totally cold, unfair, cruel, and destructive - though it often comes very close to that...closer every day now....
A mitigating "logical" concept has been that of "enlightened self-interest" - i.e., making token efforts to show the masses that your pathologically avaricious trillionaire self is sometimes actually "generous" and "caring" - and hopefully they won't threaten you. The great concern I have is that more and more humans are falling for that gambit, as existential, intrapersonal,and interpersonal intelligences appear to be weakening rapidly - and more and more of humanity accepts "greed is good", "war is peace", and other nightmarish Orwellian tropes. But all this was prophesied long ago as inevitable during the climax and collapse of Kali Yuga.
Love them as I do, we still must accept that neither a dolphin nor a gorilla could ever build architectural wonders like the Pyramids, the Eiffel Tower, or the Great Wall of China, nor keep detailed inscribed records for posterity, nor create anything like a laptop computer (or even electricity) - and certainly nothing like Artificial Intelligence. Humans still have a clear advantage in cold logical-mathematical intelligence. BUT that is only one intelligence out of NINE.
At the same time, dolphins and gorillas have interpersonal and naturalist intelligences that make those of humankind in general seem savagely primitive. These two intelligences were not deliberately programmed into homo sapiens. Just look at the calamities throughout the world today, then think back to the Roman Colosseum, the Inquisitions, the Nazis, the oil industries, plastics choking our oceans, your daily news today...ad infinitum. Much to our shame, dolphins and gorillas stay in mutually supportive groups, welcome others into their clans, protect each other, show genuine concern, even for human beings! And they would never stupidly destroy their own environment as humankind has been doing for ages.
Amen, brother! I could not have said it better! The great French writer, Gustave Flaubert, wrote: "The Earth has limits, but human stupidity is infinite." Einstein is reputed to have said something very similar.