An evil critical Virgo

[Lynda223]

Originally Posted by poyi

I try to put this in a polite manner. If I, in anyway is being inappropriate just tell me so.

I don't think that is appropriate to criticise another zodiac this way. If you do criticise All Virgo as if all Virgo are pure evil; I wonder if you are also a Virgo because in the whole world only Virgo does that according to your own references as you had listed above.

Virgo is part of the horoscope wheel and everyone has a house/cusp under Virgo. With or without a planet in that house, everyone has a Virgo in their chart.

I never stated other signs cannot have these traits. I stated Virgo consistantly has them. Also my references are for those with Sun in Virgo only. I am well aware that it is common to have Virgo in different aspects of charts. As you have demonstrated, flawed basic comprehension is also a Virgo characteristic.

[Judy_AzVirgo]

This thread is just too funny, and so very far from being realistic.

Maybe it's just my flawed basic comprehension at work here, but I think the bottom line is that those who criticize Virgo can't handle being criticized, and so they over-react. But to turn around and criticize one-twelfth of the world's population?

[Moog]

We're caught in an infinite Virgo loop.

[StillOne]

Originally Posted by Judy_AzVirgo

This thread is just too funny, and so very far from being realistic.

Maybe it's just my flawed basic comprehension at work here, but I think the bottom line is that those who criticize Virgo can't handle being criticized, and so they over-react. But to turn around and criticize one-twelfth of the world's population?

I think this (the bolded) could be very true.

However, I do think this thread is very unproductive. I had made a post earlier that I decided to remove because it doesn't promote good astrology. When you are only taking the Sun sign in consideration, without the whole chart, it's too generalized and sweeping.

Not all Virgos are evil and critical! This thread should really be closed, IMO.

[poyi]

I wasn't very interested to reply anymore. But after reading your replies. I also find it funny and ridiculous!! lol

[Judy_AzVirgo]

Originally Posted by StillOne

This thread should really be closed, IMO.

I agree, StillOne. Even the title of this thread is inflammatory.

[Caro]

Originally Posted by Judy_AzVirgo

This thread is just too funny, and so very far from being realistic.

Maybe it's just my flawed basic comprehension at work here, but I think the bottom line is that those who criticize Virgo can't handle being criticized, and so they over-react. But to turn around and criticize one-twelfth of the world's population?

That is the funniest quote of all in a thread about virgo's being critical! Pure comic gold.

and to lighten further.

the comic strip on astrodienst - that plays on stereotypes.

http://www.astro.com/col/zodiactopia_e.htm

did you hear about the virgo who washed the inside of her washing machine. a friend of mine did this - awesome!

[Judy_AzVirgo]

Originally Posted by Caro

did you hear about the virgo who washed the inside of her washing machine. a friend of mine did this - awesome!

I've done this. Sometimes the washer doesn't completely rinse out stuff like dog hair. (Yes, despite being a Virgo, I have two messy, hairy dogs that I love, and a messy, hairy Cancer I love even more.)

[JUPITERASC]

Originally Posted by Judy_AzVirgo

This thread is just too funny, and so very far from being realistic.

And a great reminder that astrological stereotyping is nonproductive and ultimately totally nonsensical... having said that I do not wish to sound overly critical

Originally Posted by Moog

We're caught in an infinite Virgo loop.

[Judy_AzVirgo]

Originally Posted by poyi

I wasn't very interested to reply anymore. But after reading your replies. I also find it funny and ridiculous!! lol

Good, Poyi! I think you should demand an apology from Linda223 for lumping you in with those nasty Virgo Sun people:

As you have demonstrated, flawed basic comprehension is also a Virgo characteristic.

[poyi]

Originally Posted by Judy_AzVirgo

Good, Poyi! I think you should demand an apology from Linda223 for lumping you in with those nasty Virgo Sun people:

Hahaha thank you for the thought Judy!!

The interesting thing about me, I thought why should I lower my class to fight with someone already made he or herself with no friend? That person is already bitter enough, I don't need to share bitterness.

[Judy_AzVirgo]

Originally Posted by JUPITERASC

And a great reminder that astrological stereotyping is nonproductive and ultimately totally nonsensical... having said that I do not wish to sound overly critical

True... and cute, even.

[Hekate]

@ Linda 223

Well, I think that I have much more of Virgo than those you have just a solar sign in.
Actually, you are right. I see myself in evil and over-criticism. The intelligence? I don't know, but I think I am very smart, almost genial.
You are so funny...this thread is really O.K.

[fullmoonlibra]

GOOOSHHH, I'm divorcing one, phieuw!!

Virgo's are sweet, but you have to handle their criticism.
I'm a relaxing Taurus and I have a Moon opposite Mercury, so I can't handle criticism.
I can't live with that.

I would not attack all Virgo's, of course, because we have to look at the whole chart BUT I'm also telling to look at your OWN chart. Can YOU handle Virgo's??

If yes, they are very serving and sweet, and their criticism is just their way to make things better. It's not bad to want things being perfect, so I don't like these black and white arguments here.

[fullmoonlibra]

Originally Posted by Judy_AzVirgo

This thread is just too funny, and so very far from being realistic.

Maybe it's just my flawed basic comprehension at work here, but I think the bottom line is that those who criticize Virgo can't handle being criticized, and so they over-react. But to turn around and criticize one-twelfth of the world's population?

Bingo...
I totally agree

[*emma*]

virgo, one of the most gentle signs to have, i have it rising, i spend 90 % of my time criticising myself, if others get it then they deserve it, not evil, just behind the libra justness which i have my sun sign in, so if i have a go im 90% right, the 10% left which is wrong is foistered with another 90% self analysis, ergo thats why virgo is an honorouble servant

[Yuusha]

Originally Posted by theV

2007-2009 that period were saturn transit virgo it was tough year for all virgo. 2012 is promising since pluto trine sun in virgo that explain why did you under those changes

@TheV Thanks for the explanation behind the 2007-2010 difficulties.

Yeah, Saturn in Virgo was really hard with its 6th house and 7th house transits, squaring natal Saturn, Uranus, the Moon...

My Sun is in 25 degrees Virgo, so Pluto isn't trining my Sun just yet, but I do imagine the next few years down the road to be very positive. Pluto is sextiling my Ascendant and my natal Pluto these days.

@fullmoonlibra

Indeed Virgos can be tough to handle. I myself can be very, very nervous and worried when I read about injustices, especially when new lows are being reached. But since I feel like a cosmic rebalance is taking place, I'm a little more hopeful.

I'm not as self-critical and critical as I used to be, but if I am critical, my worries usually have a Sagittarian edge to them or a Virgoan and Saturnian blend to them.

However, it is true that I am someone who likes to help, especially if it's in a genuine and effective manner.

[vlsmercury7]

Originally Posted by *emma*

virgo, one of the most gentle signs to have, i have it rising, i spend 90 % of my time criticising myself, if others get it then they deserve it, not evil, just behind the libra justness which i have my sun sign in, so if i have a go im 90% right, the 10% left which is wrong is foistered with another 90% self analysis, ergo thats why virgo is an honorouble servant

Same here @ *emma* I'm mostly gentle and spend a lot of my time criticizing myself more than I criticize others. However, I still have those criticism nodules should anyone mess with a member of my family or if I witness cruelty to an animal, child, elderly or vulnerable person. If I do criticize, it's because I want to help, and I try to use constructive criticism with a sense of humour, otherwise it can all come out really harsh. I have Sun, Moon, Mercury, Jupiter and Chiron all in Aries, Venus in Taurus, Mars in Aquarius, so I rarely lose my temper.

[may28gemini]

i don't think Virgo is evil but they are easily depressed and very codependent because mutable earth is rough. i suspect Virgo sun people feel earthquakes fairly often when it comes to their ego unless they have something strengthening/solidifying them like conj/trine/sextile saturn and/or conj/trine/sextile jupiter.

as a Mercury person, i understand my classmate Virgo. i like them because they tend to be rational people but very, very uncomfortable with emotions... which could make them act the fool. often. it's all very sad. you cannot be too angry for long. it does you no good and it doesn't do anything for your friend either. you will just have to let your friend face his demons alone because you cannot save anyone from themselves. maybe one day you and him will be friends again. maybe you won't. friends, like everything else in the world will come and go. don't hold your breath, and don't waste it either. save it for cooling your own porridge.

[Caro]

Originally Posted by may28gemini

they are easily depressed and very codependent because mutable earth is rough.

hey tend to be rational people but very, very uncomfortable with emotions...

I agree with this.

hence they are good at clinical stuff(doctors with starched white coats), giving the data(mathematicians/statician), talking about research(scientist) and its conclusions but not good at bringing it into the context of human life with all its complexities on a feeling and emotional level.

[may28gemini]

Originally Posted by Caro

I agree with this.

hence they are good at clinical stuff(doctors with starched white coats), giving the data(mathematicians/statician), talking about research(scientist) and its conclusions but not good at bringing it into the context of human life with all its complexities on a feeling and emotional level.

Actually, Mercury people, not just Virgo are like that. I have a lot of Mercury but it's all in Gemini and to be honest, I really HATE feelings and emotions. I'd rather that just dies off. Mercury does not care about emotions- his or others. In many ways, Mercury is like Saturn, only not as mean, but pretty insensitive and definitely like cutting off emotions and going with the objective. That's why Gemini and Virgo people get bad reps. Sure, shoot the messengers. We don't care how you feel, just face the facts.

[Caro]

Originally Posted by may28gemini

Actually, Mercury people, not just Virgo are like that. .

yes i agree gemini/mercury are less emotional.
but have to think of the descriptions for gemini's as dont see them as clinical types.

obviously softened by a venus in cancer for example.

[may28gemini]

You're right. Gemini isn't clinical but Gemini people are very analytical and detached and we present information in an interesting way. Gemini people are critical but we present that differently- less naggy and more fun.

[Caro]

I think a mercury in gemini archetype is somoene reporting from the war zone or after a disaster has occurred. They have to get soources of information quickly and assess tthe locality and its people put together a story for the news/media. presenting this in a dispassionate way. (sources may not be as accurate as the data analysis/virgo type) speed is the important component here and talking to people(all types).

[Judy_AzVirgo]

Clinical types? Right. I always wear a white lab coat when I'm looking at astrology charts.