JUPITERASC
Well-known member
tsmall is a respected and authoritative member of our forumThis post is written in hope that someone actually willing to answer the OP question may use their expertese to do so. I too am genuinely interesed whether the original question has been a factor in this disappearance.
For the record, just because linguistic graduates in the the media, who write for sensationalism, speculate that something is not true does not have any relation whatsoever to objective phenomena in the universe. There may be no proof that aliens exist but there is also no proof that aliens do not exist (and, no, I do not wish to get into a debate about it here). Thus casting the question as invalid on the assumption they do not exist is logically falacious.
As to horary being a method for definite questions and definite answers, this is a definite question. The OP has said they were not taking the issue for a joke. As for definite answers, there have been questions asking whether people have cast black magic spells on them and received a definite answer by those who have more definitive expertese in reading such charts.
If this is a learning, and not a debate, forum and posters are sceptical about the issue then it is a common courtesy to watch the thread and learn from those more experienced rather than turning the thread into a rediculing debate.
and an experienced student of Horary astrology
so, taking your advice, let's learn from tsmall
tsmall stated
Clearly then,Regarding the chart...it really wouldn't matter if someone wanted to discover if aliens abducted the plane (although it does seem as if the news outlets are beginning to have evidence that the plane was hijacked); casting a horary chart for this type of event isn't the way to go. As has already been pointed out on several of the threads here at AW about the flight, as well as on the many, many other astrology forums out there.
Let's just use a bit of logic here.
Imagine that every astrologer decided at some point over the last several days to query the Universe and cast a chart about this plane.
How many charts, with how many ascendants, would we end up with?
Too many.
That is why we use an event chart for these matters,
as Zarathu has already done on another thread.
I personally am not in possession of enough time (I have other charts working) or interest, but if I did I would want to
look at the chart from the moment the flight took off, and possibly compare it to a chart for the moment the plane disappeared from radar.
for reasons highlighted by an experienced Horary student astrologer
the question by the OP is not the way to go
The rules governing HoraryThe OP stated a desire to learn horary, and to use this chart to do so.
A mistake, for certain,
but having that pointed out is not a reason to abruptly pull out of a forum in a huff
after stating that believing in astrology was on par with believing in aliens
and choosing to decide his/her fellowship after the responses of two members.
I'm sorry, but that is the behavior of someone who is either too sensitive to be on a forum,
or someone who is looking to create trouble. Just my own opinion/experience.
Lilly himself did at least once cast a chart to determine the fate of an overdue ship.
The difference between this
(and any other curiosity chart)
is
the the querent in that case had a vested interest in the ship.
So in the case of the missing plane,
if a family member of one of the passengers or crew went to an astrologer to discover the fate of the flight,
that chart would be valid.
Otherwise. NO.
indicate that the OP question is not valid
for the reasons stated