Zodiac Signs are areas in the sky that contain stars. These areas are also called Constellations.
But what affect us are the planets, the Sun and the Moon. They are placed in the Zodiac Constellations.
I'm waiting your answer about Jupiter who's chilling somewhere else than Taurus. He is chilling in Aries. What do you think about this situation?
If you were not an educated author (of a book on this new Astrology), and I'm assuming the administer of that website that promotes your book, I would have given up long ago. I do respect your opinion and think it worth the time for us to understand the nature of Astrology. But, you are not listening to either of us, and it may be we do not appear to be listening to you, either. The fact that you do not think I have answered your question of where Jupiter is reflects your incomprehension of the concept we are trying to explain.
In our argument, the stars and signs are independent from one another to the point of there being a difference between where the constellations are and where we consider the signs to be. IF the stars do not form the signs, THEN the signs are not entirely affected by the stars. Remember! This is our side, ok?
My understanding is as follows: This key point, the Vernal Equinox, is where the Tropical Zodiac begins. This is where the signs begin. From there, each signs follows as 30 degrees of the 360 possible as viewed from earth. WHEREVER that point happens to be in the constellations is where 0 degrees Aries is. It does not matter where the constellation of Pisces is to define the Vernal Equinox. This is why your astronomical data is irrelevant.
Are you hearing this?
In your argument, I understand that the Vernal Equinox point moves in the constellations and even the constellations move themselves(as our entire solar system moves in relation to other systems), and how Jupiter is, at the time, in the constellation of Aries. Even the individual stars move within the constellations, right?
This movement does not affect where the zodiac begins, because the stars are NOT where the signs are! That point of the Equinox IS the sign of Aries, where the cycle begins. NOT the stars. Does this make sense? Lol. NOT THE STARS. Even if this is your theory, wherein the zodiac IS the constellations, you are misrepresenting ours. Or, in the least, portraying a profound misunderstanding of the Tropical Zodiac, and how Astrology works in this system.
As Frank said, if you cannot understand this, then it's hardly worth continuing.