Vocational Guess?

[Shining Ray]

deleted post

[sskohli]

hi SR
i lose out on these quizzes because i can't create the charts the vedic way.
Can you please post their birth details (maybe in pm, if you don't want others to find out :D)
thanks
sandeep

[starlink]

Hi Shining Ray, I think

No.1 = Political debater (STrong 3rd house and Ruler in 4. Mars in house of Capricorn, a political sign , showing strong political enthousiasm) Moon in Scorpio in 5, ruler Mars in 10. Lots of Fire.

No. 2 = Analyst, Investor (8th house Sun and Moon), Pluto in the 1st

No. 3= Musician (Packed 5th house, Neptune & Moon inclusive) ruler in 12 (lot of studying alone)

Wonder how wrong I am.

[wilsontc]

Ray,

Adding onto starlink's post:

Chart 1 - North node (future goals) focused in the 3rd house (thinking, also talking) - debater

Chart 2 - Pluto (transformation, also outer world money) opposite (energy is over-excited by) Venus (physical, also personal money) - stock analyst

Chart 3 - Grand Trine (including the Midheaven) that includes the 5th house (self-expression, also performing arts) - musician

Guessing,

Tim

[starlink]

Ah yes Tim, the grand trine in chart 3 is indeed another indication, must have been too focussed on the other things to mention it.

[sskohli]

chart 1 = debater (lots of 3s 11s 12s terse orator..beats the competition)
chart 2 = stock market analysor (strong 7 business inclinations)
chart 3 = violinist (5,9,11 bliss)

woah cool..our answers match :)
sandeep

(p.s. - am i right shine am i ... tugs at her pants.. woof woof :))

[Lissa]

I think the3rd chart belongs to the violinist.Four planets in the5th house(creativity),with the Moon and Neptune there.Both the Moon and the Sun are being disposed by Venus,showing lots of grace and probably good musical skills as well.

For the2nd chart I'm going to say it's the stock analyst.Both the luminaris are in the8th house of other people's money.

This leaves out the1st chart as the politician/debater but I'm not sure about what would make this person a skilled debater:confused:.

[Lissa]

Oh darn,I got them all wrong:eek:

[starlink]

"Wow"! That was a very good one Shining Ray!! Nobody got it right! How on earth is that possible. Now, would it be possible for you to give an explanation for this? I mean, what are the indicators in these charts? It is funny, but about a week ago I looked in an astrology study book where they had about 10 charts of very famous writers etc and there also, no way I could have figured that out. Like no 3rd house planets, no Gemini, you know, the typical writers signature. Incredible. So these are another example how difficult it is to see what someone is doing career wise.

[Vulcan]

"Wow"! That was a very good one Shining Ray!! Nobody got it right! How on earth is that possible. Now, would it be possible for you to give an explanation for this? I mean, what are the indicators in these charts? .
I'm myself working on a theory that the 10th shows only where you can most easily get a career, but the outcome may be compromise between that and personal desires, peer pressure etc. On the other hand, the 4th is where it will be most difficult career-wise (and since it's an employer's job market in most countries today, practically impossible). In this case the third had Sun ruling 4th, so politican unlikely (all politicans have ambition and drive to lead). Politics is also essentially about conflict a kind of constant warfare, so the Venus for the 2nd does not bother me. The violinist (which is a bit unusual) can be the Saturn (classical) in 10th trine to Neptune (I use equal). Venus is more often the appreciator of art than the actual artist.

[starlink]

the 10th shows only where you can most easily get a career,

Yes, that is not a bad way of looking at it. Very often I get someone who is unhappy in his or her job and then I look at the 10th, but also at the 5th of selfexpression by the way and ask: "but why did you then not become this" (whatever the 10th house etc. show) . And the answer is almost always because the father wanted something else, or the mother wanted her daughter to follow in her footsteps etc. So they end up doing something totally different and most of the time not happy doing it.
In this case the third had Sun ruling 4th, so politican unlikely
I dont see this. Only in the 3rd chart does the Sun rule the 4th. In the 1st chart the Sun is in the 3rd house, but it is not ruling the 4th house! Venus is.
The Politician is the second chart according to Shining Ray. Here we see Venus in Capricorn, and Capricorn is very strongly related to politics and conjunct Mercury, expression in the 7th, the public in opposition to Pluto in the 1st, very strong expression, probably not so popular with his ideas I guess. But it was not easy to see from these positions and certainly not from a Mars in Pisces ruling the 10th!

[sskohli]

Hey SR,
Here are the answers Sandeep, woof woof

hehe :D darn..i was never good with vocations..
but then neither of the westerns got it right too :D

sandeep
(P.S: You are serious SR about the results???:p)

[starlink]

By the way, nice song Shiny!