Which relationship is more intense???

[Girl_from_Jupiter]

From an astrological point of view: Which one of the following two relationships is the better one? Which of the two girls should the guy choose, if his decision was based solely on astrology? Which of the two girls would he feel more connection (both emotional and physical) with?

Personally, I feel that he would feel more attracted (both on a physical and an emotional level) to girl #1, but maybe I'm wrong.

I would be very grateful for any help I can get with this!!!

Relationship #1:

(guy on the inside/girl #1 on the outside)

http://i162.photobucket.com/albums/t258/girl_from_jupiter/guy_girl1.jpg
http://i162.photobucket.com/albums/t258/girl_from_jupiter/aspects_girl1.jpg

Relationship #2:

(guy on the inside/girl #2 on the outside)

http://i162.photobucket.com/albums/t258/girl_from_jupiter/guy_girl2.jpg
http://i162.photobucket.com/albums/t258/girl_from_jupiter/aspects_girl2.jpg

[wilsontc]

Girl,

First of all, NO relationship is entirely based on astrology! ;) There is this thing called "reality" that can mess up our great astrological system so sometimes people who "shouldn't" get together do...and STAY together. We can't rule out personal choice in relationships.

However, to play along, if relationships were ALL about astrology, then certainly the mutual Pluto (transformation, also power) - Venus (relationships) connections of Combo 1 is stronger than the no Pluto-Venus connections (leaving out the aspects which, in my opinion, are too large to be counted) of Combo 2. Combo 1 could make a VERY intense relationship.

To look for an "emotional" connection to the guy for Couple 1 we look to planetary contacts to his Moon. For that Couple 2 seems more intense (leaving out the aspects which, in my opinion, are too large to be counted).

To look for a "physical" connection we look to planetary contact to Venus. For that Couple 1 seems MUCH stronger.

Of course, the guy DOES have a lot to say in the matter, so we'll just see if he goes with "Door #1" or "Door #2"! ;)

Relating,

Tim

[rahu]

if you post the birthdata i could run some composite charts on these people.
rahu

[Girl_from_Jupiter]

Thank you both for your insight!!!

I don't feel comfortable posting their birthdata ... I really appreciate the generous offer, though.:)