Are we over for good? Is our relationship done?

[CatchMe]

I want to know if we are over for good? He didn't contact me this weekend, and our relationship has been on the rocks.. I'm sad about this all and want to know if we are really over for good this time. Please let me know what you think.. Thanks!

http://img266.imageshack.us/img266/2475/astrow2gw01isourrelatio.gif

[Serendipity]

I realize you're new but you should make an attempt at trying to read your own chart.
Also, this is your 4th or 5th question on the same guy in about a week. Horary is not meant to work like a magic 8 ball.

[dr. farr]

Repost the expired chart and I'll use the Magic 8 Ball to see what it says:sideways:!
(Note: the Magic 8 Ball technique is not horary, its a form of astro-divination; Serendipity's statement about repeated related questions re to the same subject, over a short period of time, is quite correct)

[Neptune Rising]

A note about Serendipity's first sentence - you are not required to make an attempt at analysing your own chart. The horary section is open for people to post without their own analysis, however as a bit of advice, it does encourage people to respond if you do at least try as it shows them that you are trying to learn. NR

[CatchMe]

In regards to Serendipity's comment, I never said horary is 8-ball magic. I have questions about my situation, and I am seeking advice from individuals that are obviously more knowledgeable in horary then I am. If you don't like my posts, or my subject matter, you don't have to read anything I'm posting on.

To Dr. Farr I've re-uploaded my chart, thanks for catching that. Your help and interpretations are always appreciated!

and to Neptune Rising thanks for letting me know. I assumed their wasn't an horary analysis rule/requirement, I'm new to this form, still learning, and will attempt to analyze my charts at my own pace. When I feel more confident in my astrological abilities. I guess you could say I'm still learning the horary ABC's.. Houses, Aspects. etc..

[misskitty]

There are several of us here who are not motivated at all to read a chart unless the querent makes some type of effort to do so themselves first. That is just because we don't want to see the site being used as a free reading site. Horary is a little different than regular astrology in that it requires the student to examine themselves and their motives in order to truly learn. That usually can't happen with people who just want free readings.

Serendipity is correct. Horary is supposed to be used when you think of the question you want to ask the most. And that question should contain all the sub-questions that will be answered with the first chart. So if you continually ask multiple charts on the same situation, even if the question itself is slightly different each time, you are only going to get charts that are confusing, unclear, or flat out wrong. In that case, you might as well buy a toy 8-ball.

My suggestion is that you should let the situation rest for a while and try not to ask any new questions for a couple of weeks. Your first chart you made on the subject will be the most accurate.

[Neptune Rising]

Lets ALL get back on topic now please, leave the horary 'free questions' debate for another board and look at the querant's question and their chart.

Thanks!
NR

[dr. farr]

(Following is an application of the experimental Walis Magic 8 Ball method of astro-divination and is not horary practice; foolowing uses whole sign house format)

Relationship = 7th house; 7th house under Capricorn, Capricorn = Saturn; therefore according to the 8 Ball "rules", the answer is "no" this relationship is not over.

(outside of the simplistic 8 Ball divination, however, the chart shows the relationship is blocked/at a standstill, because relationship significator Saturn-lord of the 7th house-is in a pitted degree; also, circumstances at this time are additionally indicated as being unfortuante because querent's significator, Moon, flows away from relationship signficator Saturn and Moon is applying to a square with Saturn, Moon is waning and is combust the Sun-difficult times for sure!)

[Serendipity]

In regards to Serendipity's comment, I never said horary is 8-ball magic. I have questions about my situation, and I am seeking advice from individuals that are obviously more knowledgeable in horary then I am. If you don't like my posts, or my subject matter, you don't have to read anything I'm posting on.You should read some background information on horary so that you'll understand why I said what I did. And that it's not for questioning every nuance of your relationship. (although some chart readers on this forum seem to think that is ok)

[rafaella]

I do think the relationsip is ending, Moon square Saturn, Moon in detriment and Moon then changes signs and becomes combust. Nothing good in this chart, unfortunately. Moon is really not in good shape, you have quite a bit of healing to do...

Also have a look at the very first chart as that might give you the most accuracy regardig your situation.

Take care!

[Neptune Rising]

You should read some background information on horary so that you'll understand why I said what I did. And that it's not for questioning every nuance of your relationship. (although some chart readers on this forum seem to think that is ok)

I understand perfectly well some background info on horary. This is not what I was refering to. I was refering specificall to your first sentance, where you said "I realize you're new but you should make an attempt at trying to read your own chart."This is NOT accurate, as I stated. People here in the horary forum are NOT required to delineate their own chart, if they choose not to. They have a choice. Elsewhere in the forum, they are required to otherwise their chart is moved to the RMC forum. Its different here in horary. Thanks, and please ALL get back to the topic. If you wish to take this up with me, please do so either in the suggestions forum or via PM.NR

[Serendipity]

I understand perfectly well some background info on horary. This is not what I was refering to. I was refering specificall to your first sentance, where you said "I realize you're new but you should make an attempt at trying to read your own chart."This is NOT accurate, as I stated. People here in the horary forum are NOT required to delineate their own chart, if they choose not to. They have a choice. Elsewhere in the forum, they are required to otherwise their chart is moved to the RMC forum. Its different here in horary. Thanks, and please ALL get back to the topic. If you wish to take this up with me, please do so either in the suggestions forum or via PM.NR What I wrote was not directed at you, nor was it in reference to the querent delineating her own chart. I was responding to what the querent stated to me and I was specifically speaking to the amount of questions created on the subject matter itself.
I've also sent you a PM